Sallu

You know what, I completely agree with those who say that the latest album is supermarket music; there are some very good things, but others are a bit less so... the fact that it reaches everyone, and by everyone I also mean the 14 horny girls, shows how it was conceived to become a mass product, far from their masterpiece (an Italian masterpiece as well) Just a big stone. In any case, I really like it.

I believe that The Strokes, and especially Interpol, are definitely not to be dismissed, quite the opposite. The Strokes may be overly hyped, but their music is good; it won't save rock, but it's good. As for Interpol, in my opinion, they're phenomenal, but whatever, it seems like fewer and fewer people think like I do. Franz Ferdinand and The Libertines also seem very genuine to me. I don't believe that the current scene is entirely to be discarded; on the contrary. Sure, it could be better, but it could also be sooo much worse.

you’re a jerk... you insist on saying that just because they have that somewhat gloomy air. So what? One thing is referencing, another thing is copying. Tell me if songs like narc, pda, nyc, stella, or a thousand others are the same as those of Joy Division. And it doesn’t seem to me that you really know anything about either Italian or music. Do you think Love Will Tear Us Apart has a chorus? When would that chorus be? When it says love will tear us apart again? Do you think that’s a chorus? You’re one of those who watched the video for Obstacle 1 and thought, "they dress in suits + baritone voice + songs that are somewhat dark about love or social alienation = Joy Division." You think you know Joy Division, but you come off as one of those idiots who only listens to old stuff because these days "there's no more music of value"... Ah, Muse have nothing to do with this, don’t bring them into it. And please don’t sign yourself as joy division.tk, you’re just tarnishing their name, thanks. P.S.: the same Hook has said that he adores Interpol and does not consider them copies of Joy Division at all, precisely because they have a different approach to music, with many more well-defined parts among them.

Now I’m going to say something controversial. But is this a book of poems or a record?

I saw them live and I was amazed at how useful Fidel was. Even in Valvonauta, he was there; they are out of this world...

We are a singles band; the singles are beautiful, even if they're all the same. You listen to them for a while and they entertain you, but they can never be your new favorite band! They are very limited.

joydivison.tk you are a complete jerk! Your ignorance about Joy Division and Interpol is beyond belief. You haven’t even grasped the different approaches they have towards music. Joy Division didn’t even have choruses in their songs, not even bridges; it was the obsessive riffs that dominated. In Interpol, there are choruses, bridges, variations, influences that are even very distant from Joy Division. You can say you prefer the ones from Manchester, but Interpol are definitely not a copy...

It's amazing how all metal CDs are masterpieces. At least you write well and you're a girl. Much respect and love to you...

I wrote it myself, and it's still better... welcome.

But here we review music, not Pokémon!