telespallabob

DeRank : 11,31 • DeAge™ : 6318 days

Voto:
Splinter, you’ve dropped the Rush and their "Psychadelia," you’ve written an acceptable review. This time you deserve 4 stars. A band that produces "a perfect calling card for MTV" shouldn’t be that great, but maybe I’m wrong.
Voto:
Comment number 11 is one of the most beautiful I've ever read, fantastic! The review isn't garbage, there are two things I can't accept! "The greatest local rocker," ARE YOU KIDDING?????? And according to the stars you give the album, you criticize it and give it 3? It doesn't make much sense. Anyway, you don't write badly, if you tackle decent albums you have a future in here.
Egg Egg
4 may 08
Voto:
And Jonah, the super expert from Canterbury here at debaser, gives us a nice review (as usual). I must disagree on the stars to give the album, which deserves 5. Anyway, Ole is right, take a break!
Voto:
Now that GreenManalishi has arrived, I can comment. Thank you for your feedback; especially Paloz, who has no need to apologize. You simply offered a critique, which should always be welcomed because it’s useful and allows you (us) to improve. I agree with GreenManalishi when he focused on "Harem Scarem," my favorite from this album.
Voto:
Good review, I listened to their tracks on Myspace and they're not bad.
Voto:
Sufficiently raw, it could have been done better. As far as I'm concerned, the idea of downloading albums from the artists' websites is interesting and commendable; I got "In Rainbows" that way. I'm not a huge fan of Nine Inch Nails, but I really appreciate them for their use of the theremin.
Voto:
Good review, well done, it's very essential. I've heard X by Schulze and it's a really great album.
Voto:
I quote Paolo, both for the rating of the review and for the judgment on Neil Peart.
Voto:
It's one of their best albums, even though they reached their peak with "In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida." The review is decent, but I'll bump it up a grade because it's the first one.
Voto:
I didn't like the review; you talked too much about the band and too little about the album. The rediscovery raises your rating.