Best artist of all time
le posizioni sono puramente casuali..e le classifiche le detesto, era per inserire artisti di riferimento.
Your comment on the chart
Comments on this chart
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    16 jun 10
    the first 3 horrendous
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    16 jun 10
    you are horrible.
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    16 jun 10
    screw you
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    16 jun 10
    Ooooh, what a scare!
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    16 jun 10
    Sure! Please provide the text you'd like me to translate.
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    16 jun 10
    culture does not belong to you, just like it doesn’t belong to others of your generation.. a wreck of values that Strummer-Dylan, if they had been alive, would have slaughtered you. Rightly so. And then Cockburn, you probably don’t even know him.. better that way. Come on, get a grip!
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    16 jun 10
    Look, you can't say that Strummer was awful. You can say he was off-key, that you don't like Punk, that what the Clash played wasn't just Punk... you can say a lot of things, but you can't criticize him as a person because he was a symbol of revolution in those years... just watch the videos, I mean to really understand the era. He was a great artist. As for Dylan, I won’t respond because there’s nothing to say, he’s a prophet. The same goes for Cockburn... he's a genius on the guitar, with techniques similar to those of Don Ross, real tough guys who know their stuff when it comes to guitar. And the lyrics are beautiful too. So...
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    16 jun 10
    Listen, if I don’t like them, that’s my business; there’s no need to say that I’m ignorant... you don’t know me, so you can make a judgment, but it’s wrong. Generalizing is a sign of ignorance, but just because of that I’m not saying you’re ignorant. Strummer is a great artist, but he’s awful (to me) in that position; then again, everyone does what they want. I don’t adore Dylan, and I obviously know Cockburn, not everything because he’s written a ton, but I can get to the end of the '70s. Who told you I was born in 1990? The nickname? So you’re really a genius... I could thus deduce that you’re 21 years old, right?
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    16 jun 10
    And then it was all a joke... Accept the criticism or don't make rankings.
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    16 jun 10
    Think about this... I'm ignorant because I don't like her favorite artists that much... this really is a great generation!!!
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    16 jun 10
    ..in fact, I didn't say it, I spoke about your generation in the sense that I had already seen you commenting in another ranking, trashing Gilmour and Dylan, so I've already figured out what kind of little brain you have, you, the ones who criticize institutions of music, that generation I mean. I can't express judgments because I don't know you, but can you tell me to f*** myself?..I wrote you’re awful for posting the first comment, well your ‘f*** yourself’ is much more offensive, coming from someone who doesn't know me..or am I wrong? So, then listen to the rest of the discography..Listen, for crying out loud..I posted a ranking, writing a little note: the positions are purely random. If you want to talk about music, I accept it, otherwise as they say where I'm from 'sciola!’.
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    16 jun 10
    Did you happen to lose the use of your little hands? Anyway, since you're new to deb (I'm new too, but I've gotten used to it), I should let you know that we tease a lot around here, so try not to be too sensitive and know-it-all. I'm saying this for your own good; it's not worth getting angry over this stuff.
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    16 jun 10
    Now don’t play the victim... you’re making me laugh though... I didn’t say you have to like them, I just said you can’t make constructive criticisms.
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    16 jun 10
    I haven't lost the use of my hands. Anyway, don't worry, I've known Deb for ages.
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    16 jun 10
    Alright, since you're new, sorry for the surprise! I don’t criticize any institution of music. Saying that I think Stummer is exaggerated among the top 15 greatest artists of all time means criticizing him?? I think if you make a ranking like that, even the five-hundredth would be a genius! Don’t come to me saying that by generation you mean what you’d like me to think... please, I’m not that stupid.
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    16 jun 10
    and then since it's not a chat, I reply when I feel like it.
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    16 jun 10
    What criticism should I make??? They are great artists, I think so too!! But do you understand? Too far above my tastes! I haven't made any constructive criticisms because there aren't any to make...
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    16 jun 10
    You can believe me or not, I don't care, I just know that there are many of you. There are those who listen to Guns and get so fixated that they say that P.Floyd are jerks, Dylan is slow, but you’ve said worse, trust me. Trust me, there's a backward reinterpretation of rock history that I don't like at all, and I'm quite scared when these empty statements are made, these false accusations that erase years of protests, of songs. I repeat this to you: as long as it's a matter of tastes, it's fine, we are different, we all have different tastes. But when it comes to beauty, objectivity must come into play. Anyway, I'm talking about constructive criticism, which I haven't really seen from you so far, but saying they’re awful without providing arguments seems reductive to me. Anyway, I’m about to lose the use of my little hands because I have to study. Until next time, if there is one...
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    16 jun 10
    I lost the use of my little hands but I respond. 1) I don’t fixate on anyone. 2) The Floyd are not fools. 3) Dylan is not slow. 4) I am not a fool. 5) I haven’t accused anyone. 6) I don’t want to erase anything. 7) Zappa protested too, in a way that is much more to my liking. 8) Beauty and objectivity go hand in hand only in Kant. 9) THEY ARE TERRIBLE NOT ABSOLUTELY, BUT IN THAT POSITION, WHICH IF IT IS NOT THE PODIUM, IS STILL AMONG THE TOP 15 ARTISTS OF ALL TIME. 10) Tastes are tastes, but I express my opinion. Until next time!
     
  • Trevor Reznik
    Trevor Reznik
    16 jun 10
    Frenk, don't take it personally, that's just how it is :D good ranking apart from ELP.
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    16 jun 10
    Enough now. Also because you don't understand the meaning of my statements. The ranking is good for me too, but there are certain things I don't agree with. Waits, Zappa, and Hendrix can objectively fit, already Waits a bit less (even though I included him too); the others no (subjectively).
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    16 jun 10
    Thank you, Trevor, why not the ELP?.. :(
     
  • Trevor Reznik
    Trevor Reznik
    16 jun 10
    the ELP are really getting on my nerves :)
     
  • Schizoid Man
    Schizoid Man
    16 jun 10
    well... Strummer is rightly in this ranking, I won't say position because it seems to me that they're placed randomly. As for the rest, I have some doubts about that little bastard Bruce Springsteen and Clapton, who after a while just rips your pants off... :D
     
  • teenagelobotomy
    teenagelobotomy
    16 jun 10
    little bastard the boss splatter??? :(
     
  • Schizoid Man
    Schizoid Man
    16 jun 10
    Yes, yes, you little bastard... I confirm! But it's just my dislike... a bit like the Rolling Stones, nothing personal :P
     
  • teenagelobotomy
    teenagelobotomy
    16 jun 10
    aaah, I understand... :D
     
  • teenagelobotomy
    teenagelobotomy
    16 jun 10
    then he’s done for... :D
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    16 jun 10
    hahahaha.. it's true Clapton gets a bit annoying after a while.. Springsteen yes sold out a bit I confess..
     
  • Cereal Killer
    Cereal Killer
    1 jul 10
    Jim Kerr between Ella Fitzgerald and Jimmy Page. What an honor for the truly great Jim! I won't express my thoughts on Springsteen, I detest him.
     
  • BORNTORUN1976
    BORNTORUN1976
    3 dec 10
    put Cockburn 10 and I'm good with that ;)
     
  • BORNTORUN1976
    BORNTORUN1976
    5 apr 11
    Strummer is not great... he is AMAZING!!!!!!
     
  • Frenk21
    Frenk21
    5 apr 11
    I'm glad you appreciate it!! Anyway, I didn't put them in order, they're scattered... the first ones that came to mind... but objectively, rankings, well... I hate those from magazines like 'the 100 best guitarists...' and then there's really amazing people light years away... well... maybe it's better not to make certain rankings... or not?
     
  • hjhhjij
    hjhhjij
    5 apr 11
    Personally, I don't like Strummer as an artist; as for the others, they are all great artists (Zappa and Hendrix above all), including ELP, even though there are significantly superior bands in the progressive genre (in my opinion). Nice ranking.
     
Similar users
Trevor Reznik

DeRank™: 0,00

manute

DeRank™: 0,38

devil65

DeRank™: 0,00

Philbass

DeAge 5551