Zarathustra

Okay, I admit I took it too much... All good now. Criticism is always helpful. Peace? :-)

"5 to this soundtrack? Oh, okay, right. It's a soundtrack, so 5 regardless."
"What do you have, the judgment decimeter? Ah, no, you use inches, that's why we don't agree."
These are provocations in Italian. See you soon.

Your attempts to provoke me are pathetic; you started doing it from the first comment and you're continuing in a rather clumsy way. I'm not used to brawls; if you don't like the album, don't listen to it, and if my reviews seem trite, don't read them. Regarding criticisms, they can be ridiculous because they make people laugh (in that case, they might also have a grain of truth as you say, even if a criticism, by definition, is not subject to the truth-falsity judgment because it is the expression of a personal point of view that, no matter how objective, is still debatable—unless we are talking about literary-philosophical criticism which, based on particular aesthetic conceptions, aims to examine and judge artistic and literary works, but don't worry, yours doesn't fall into this category) or they can be awkward, clumsy, and insignificant, and for this reason exposed to ridicule and laughter. Reread yours and see well into which category to place it. With this, on my part, the discussion is over, unless you find the willingness to talk seriously about music, without sterile provocations.

In my opinion, that’s what’s truly beautiful: music merging perfectly with images and scenes, slipping through the folds of the film almost unnoticed. An intrusive soundtrack, in my opinion, is not a good soundtrack; of course, this is debatable, but if I’m writing a review, I naturally present my point of view. For me, the perfect soundtrack is one whose presence you hardly notice (because it's obviously perfectly integrated into the film).

I almost forgot..
@superpanta: sorry, out of curiosity, what do you think of Musica Ricercata No. 2 from "Eyes Wide Shut"? It's trivial too, right? After all, it's three piano notes a minute... Maybe that guy is also compositively incapable? Soundtracks need to fit the films; perhaps that’s not clear to you. Music is subordinate to the film; it doesn't have to be brilliant at all costs because that's not what it's designed for.

@Know-it-all: if I liked the soundtrack for the reasons I mentioned above, where’s the problem in giving it the maximum? The criticisms made just for the sake of it are ridiculous, and don’t try to confuse me with people who don’t understand anything and give a 5 to anything that strays from the idea of popular music.

Are you kidding? What do you understand about the music of this album?

Put "pop" which is the right label.

Look, these reviews make me lose the desire to engage with this site. I have some things to say about the album, but I will refrain because the review doesn't merit starting a discussion.

Hehe, actually I like it too, she...