JimMorrison

Of course they can't be compared, it seems obvious to me. It's just that I consider the aforementioned groups to be among the best on the market. Although different. See you soon!

Beautiful review for the absolute masterpiece of Pink Floyd. It almost felt like I was listening to the album again.
I completely disagree with Primiballi. Isn't the Statue of Liberty a naked man? That's news to me. :-P. Jokes aside. Waters a great genius of words and voice? I'm totally on board with the words; they always move me, but the voice is a tad out of tune. Just listen to the album The Final Cut and you'll realize Roger's glaring off-notes (I want to emphasize that I have a lot of respect for him) covered by the sax and effects.
It's true: Floyd with Syd (but also with Dave and Roger, let’s be clear) would have been different. They would have been better.

For Claudio: but do you like this album or not? You say it's a masterpiece, to be recommended, etc. etc. and then you tell me that "US AND THEM, slow and irritably almost boring." Well. I believe it's actually the best song on an album that never rises to the levels of what the Floyd did before. It’s, of course, a personal opinion.

Great. Almost as much as Steely Dan.
For "The Punisher": pprrrrrrrrrrrrr

A satisfactory review for a lysergic, vibrant album. The best Floyd album alongside The Piper.
To puntiniCAZpuntini: you’re a legend! Send me a picture of yourself so I can make a poster for my room. :-)