puntiniCAZpuntini

DeRank : 14,44 • DeAge™ : 8166 days

  • Contact
  • Here since 21 october 2003
Voto:
Well, they made the first punkish album, the Clash, but then they went much further. That was a band with ideas, no doubt about it, but they weren't doing punk in the strictest sense of the term.
Voto:
But they had IDEAS, you don't want to put together a diverse and brilliant group, especially one that played when it was all countryside (the VU), with those poor assholes who in the 80s claimed to be making a revolution?
Voto:
The Clash are in the punk MOVEMENT, but what kind of punk do they have? And above all, God Save The Queen doesn’t sound like "Fuck The Queen" to me, and also, saying that Area were posers is a huge stretch, given they probably even killed people. Ever heard of the Brigate Rosse? (I’m not saying "long live Area because of BR," I’m just saying that saying they were posers is objectively A HUGE LOAD OF BULLSHIT.)
Voto:
Never said otherwise, I vote for myself because this was a stroke of genius.
Voto:
Yes, a topic to argue about, yes, but it’s different from a thesis. A thesis is a thesis if it’s based on objective data; in music, there isn’t any objective data, and that’s why it bothers me to be seen as someone who thinks otherwise. So if you tell me "you’re not convincing me" or "what the hell are you saying?" or "go fuck yourself," I don’t give a damn. If you say that "my thesis has gaps," you’re putting me on the same level as imbeciles like Scaruffi, and I don’t like that. As for PS, I write on Debaser because I enjoy it, not to get musical opinions.
Voto:
Again with this thesis thing about the Bogus, I couldn't care less about convincing you or making a thesis, I state my opinion and that's it. The Buzzcocks are a good punk band, but on a global scale, they are nothing, the Stranglers the same, the Damned the same,... the Clash, what do they have that’s punk? Thesis, theories, that's not for me, I couldn't care less about what others think nor do I want to convince them. It's not a thesis, it's an opinion... punk sucks, that’s all there is to it.
Voto:
Ajeje, it's also true that there are great albums, okay, in general it's all crap, just like rap is generally crap. Two non-music genres, with a few small exceptions, and between the two, I find punk more repulsive for millions of reasons that I won't list, including many reasons beyond the music.
Voto:
Do wastes slide? And why? Am I perhaps apologizing? No. Am I changing my thesis? No, I even wrote it in the review that this is a concept against punk. On what mirrors am I leaning if I’ve only reiterated things stated above? And have you ever read or heard an interview with Demetrio Stratos to say that it's not so? When someone tries to apologize, they climb on the mirrors or change the subject; I reaffirm and endorse every word written in this review, from the review itself to the comments. What are you talking about?
Björk Post
1 aug 05
Voto:
A person I trust speaks highly of it, says that it’s back in full trilli-campanelle-violini-cazzi-maz zi-gigi-dibiagio, zero minimalism like Medulla but with stories just like in the old days.
Voto:
link rotto <- the new album by Bjork has been released.