puntiniCAZpuntini

DeRank : 14,44 • DeAge™ : 7994 days

  • Contact
  • Here since 21 october 2003
Voto:
Deep Throat suggests some texts from the student movement of the 60s and 70s to Lord Henry, who has a somewhat confused idea of what music those people listened to. One thing is for sure, it was NOT Punk.
Voto:
Yes, but there are trendsetters and TOTAL IDIOTS. Sorry, I hadn’t read this ABSURD NONSENSE -> ""punk reflected a specific historical period of changes (abortion, divorce, feminism, student movements, workers)"" <- WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU SAYING? Are you even familiar with the Italian and European political scene of the 70s? STUDENT MOVEMENTS REFLECTED BY... PUNK???? WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU SAYING? THIS IS A B N O R M A L.
Voto:
I say this very lightly because we're talking about bullshit, Deep Throat, bullshit, are you there? Music and various crap like records and CDs. For me, someone who was in the midst of activist groups back then is a murderer; I don't just blame those who physically placed the bombs, the blame is on all those who supported such things. And I have nothing to study, that the Area were far left, but far far far left, they said it and they still say it. Moving the discussion to the Br doesn't interest me at all; we were talking about an alleged "fanciness" of the Area, I said "that's not true" because it's not true. Then if you want to mess with your head about the Br, go ahead.
Voto:
But indeed I wrote "they can't play and THEY HAVE NO IDEAS." Read carefully before writing, those who started it all had the idea of stripping things down to the bone, those who blew up in '77 were just FUCKING TRENDIES.
Voto:
I have never done any equations, but their far-left militancy is well known, not to mention obvious and declared: they have always denied being part of activist groups, but who is the idiot that when asked "are you part of the BR?" replies "Sure, arrest me, go ahead."
Voto:
Well, they made the first punkish album, the Clash, but then they went much further. That was a band with ideas, no doubt about it, but they weren't doing punk in the strictest sense of the term.
Voto:
But they had IDEAS, you don't want to put together a diverse and brilliant group, especially one that played when it was all countryside (the VU), with those poor assholes who in the 80s claimed to be making a revolution?
Voto:
The Clash are in the punk MOVEMENT, but what kind of punk do they have? And above all, God Save The Queen doesn’t sound like "Fuck The Queen" to me, and also, saying that Area were posers is a huge stretch, given they probably even killed people. Ever heard of the Brigate Rosse? (I’m not saying "long live Area because of BR," I’m just saying that saying they were posers is objectively A HUGE LOAD OF BULLSHIT.)
Voto:
Never said otherwise, I vote for myself because this was a stroke of genius.
Voto:
Yes, a topic to argue about, yes, but it’s different from a thesis. A thesis is a thesis if it’s based on objective data; in music, there isn’t any objective data, and that’s why it bothers me to be seen as someone who thinks otherwise. So if you tell me "you’re not convincing me" or "what the hell are you saying?" or "go fuck yourself," I don’t give a damn. If you say that "my thesis has gaps," you’re putting me on the same level as imbeciles like Scaruffi, and I don’t like that. As for PS, I write on Debaser because I enjoy it, not to get musical opinions.