3POUNDSOFLOVE is having trouble posting comments (dwarfs do something, he's not the only one....), so I'm posting a comment he sent me via email that he absolutely wanted to share, which I find very, very interesting... ------------
"… right now I can’t post comments on the discussion about emotive, it won’t let me leave messages. However, this is what I intended to write about copyright issues. CAZ works like this: you sign a contract for a certain number of albums (generally). And you get paid for that. The more the record sells, the money gets split: 1. the record label; 2. the copyright; 3. the wholesale distributor; 4. the retail distributor.
A Perfect Circle earns point two only for 2 twelfths on emotive. Rather than thieves then. Some leave the record label with 3 compilations, 2 DVDs, a live album, etc., and others leave a record like this as collateral. With the release of emotive (and amotion), A Perfect Circle is free/unemployed.
To give you a practical example, without mentioning the case of Mary Guybert, Alice in Chains, evidently when Layne was still intact, had signed for a certain number of albums. Definitely before the self-titled, probably after Jar of Flies. Since the release of their last album of unreleased material, they have come out in order, besides various VHS/DVD formats, with the following LPs: MTV Unplugged, Nothing Safe - Best of the Box, Music Bank Box Set, Live, Greatest Hits, Best of.
It doesn’t take much to realize that Jerry and company haven’t given up the money specified in their contract by agreeing to the production of these releases rather than terminating the agreement. A case from these days is that of Pearl Jam, coming out after numerous bootlegs (not for Epic, including the latest Benaroya), after 2 live DVDs in 3 years, after Lost Dogs, a collection of b-sides, with a Greatest Hits/Best of without unreleased tracks, to get out of their contract with Sony/Epic, which, let’s be honest, has always supported their every whim, see the logic of not appearing. We’ll see what they do, if they really sign with an indie label. I believe very little in that.
Clear who the thieves are? (far be it from me to criticize the music of Alice in Chains, Pearl Jam, and Jeff Buckley, whom I loved not too long ago).
A similar case to that of A Perfect Circle, on the other hand, is for example Renegades by RATM. All the money goes to the songwriters. I confirm 5/5 to the band."