Stephen King It
Stephen King It
30 nov 08
Voto:
Logan, it seems slightly contradictory to claim that criticism is crap on a review site. The opinion of those who know more than you is always important. It helps to understand a work. Then it is right to form an individual and subjective judgment.
Stephen King It
Stephen King It
30 nov 08
Voto:
Okay, it lifts my spirits to know that you read something else too. Better for you. But it doesn't change the fact that you bought King at the supermarket. He he... how easy it is to make you mad. I adore you when you're furious.
Stephen King It
Stephen King It
29 nov 08
Voto:
I also didn't want to offend anyone, Logan. No problem.
Tool Undertow
Tool Undertow
29 nov 08
Voto:
You're too much of a fool. So 5
Stephen King It
Stephen King It
29 nov 08
Voto:
In short, I wanted to highlight the excessive enthusiasm for what I consider to be a good commercial product and nothing more. If one has truly read great literature, one cannot define King as immense, grand, monumental, or a masterpiece... It seems right to place him in his proper context, which will never be among the greats of literature. Look, it would be, making a musical comparison, like being presented with any commercial artist (like U2 or Madonna) as if they were innovative and genius. Let's say you have a more refined and sophisticated musical taste, okay? But one does not live by art alone. I hope I’ve made myself clear and haven't upset you, Girasole. Though getting you riled up is hardly a monumental task.
Stephen King It
Stephen King It
29 nov 08
Voto:
Of course, I only mentioned them to remind us of true masters of literature, certainly not to compare them. It seemed so obvious to me. Did I perhaps make a comparison? On the contrary, I cited them (and there are others) to highlight the chasm that exists between a B-list literary master and true great authors. Given that in these lines, they all seem to drool at the mere mention of a name, and you yourself present it as an essential cornerstone. It's B-list material, mental gymnastics (even entertaining and well-crafted) for uncritical masses who have read nothing else (like probably you too) than what they pick off the shelves of a supermarket.
Crystal Antlers Crystal Antlers
Crystal Antlers Crystal Antlers
28 nov 08
Voto:
Excellent report.
Stephen King It
Stephen King It
28 nov 08
Voto:
Okay, I respect your tastes. I understand that it might be enjoyable, in its own (fucking) way he might be a master, but I wouldn't go so far as to call him an artist or a genius. He's good at writing absurd nonsense.
Stephen King It
Stephen King It
27 nov 08
Voto:
Sunflower, as always you write wonderfully. I fear you know much more about music than about literature.
Stephen King It
Stephen King It
27 nov 08
Voto:
No Logan, you are right. King is a genius. Just like Conrad, Joyce, Proust, Mann, Tolstoy, and others that you surely have never read. Only this can explain your perception of this carnival phenomenon whose rightful place is the shelves of any hypermarket.
Similar users
Groups
SantoNatal
ScieMenZiaTi
MusicofiliAttivi
W_I_NEGRI
Cactus
RadioDelirio
DeDentro
Fante
Electroma
Championship
CasoUmano
Capish
Enigmatico
Tutausend
DeBastards
Supercazzolaro
Rewards
january 2016
week 39 - 2010
week 2 - 2016
week 44 - 2016
week 40 - 2017
week 50 - 2017
week 22 - 2018
week 36 - 2019
week 5 - 2022