GustavoTanz

And then I read people giving it 1... tastes are tastes, but 1 seems unacceptable to me.

One of the most beautiful metal albums of recent years. I need to track down the latest one instead...

"Holy Christ, 5 stars for this one, and what do we give to Dark Side or Peter Gabriel then, 18?" "But in life you make comparisons, and 5 stars for this tufo is really too much..." I wanted to tell you this almost a year ago, but I’ll say it now: Marpado, you disappoint me far too much, just like The_dull_flame disappointed me. I don’t think it’s the worst thing in the world to give 5 stars to a CD like "Eva Contro Eva" by Consoli. What worries me more is reading here on DeBaser about people (not all idiots, eh) who give 5 (or 4) to "De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas" by Mayhem, "Misantropo A Senso Unico" by Cripple Bastards, "Louder Than Hell" or "Gods Of War" by Manowar, or even to "Results May Vary" and "Chocolate Starfish And The Hot Dog Flavoured Water" by Limp Bizkit, which from what I've heard are among the worst albums I've ever had the misfortune to listen to, that mediocre CD "Numb" by Linea 77 (who have also made some good stuff, mind you) is a masterpiece in comparison. Then, I don’t think comparisons should ALWAYS be made, but of course it depends on how I feel. In the case of Consoli, I don’t think it’s appropriate to say "If you give 5 to Consoli, how much do you give to XXX?" Marpado, out of curiosity, can you tell me who are the Italian artists you like, aside from Battisti and Mia Martini (undeniably historical)?

Marpado, you used to be mildly likable, but I'm really starting to get tired of your almost always negative comments. By what criteria do you allow yourself to say that Bandabardò only says "Berlusconi merda," etc.? Have you ever carefully read their lyrics? I hope you respond because otherwise it’s clear you don't want to engage in discussion... p.s. I am neither left nor right.

Some nice songs, but nothing more. Starblazer, listen to whatever you want, but don't call a CD like this a MASTERPIECE when it has absolutely NOTHING of a MASTERPIECE.

I only needed the singles to understand how this CD seems STRA-overrated to me. If I ever happen to listen to it in full, I wouldn't be surprised if I ended up judging it as one of the most overrated CDs ever.

THAT = THAT SONG ;)

Well, Dreamwarrior, I only know the one by the Survivor. I should have specified above that sooner or later I’ll have to listen to this CD...

Anyway, "Eye Of The Tiger" is and remains a historic piece... :) and fuck Filippo De Maria.

Icnarf, let it go. That's a droid with broken fuses.