Cover of Tokio Hotel Scream
Trimalchione

• Rating:

For fans of emo rock, critics of pop-punk bands, followers of early 2000s rock trends, and listeners interested in music reviews of german bands
 Share

THE REVIEW

Not knowing what else to do, yesterday afternoon I had the unfortunate idea of watching MTV and found four kids playing (?) something more plastic than Britney Spears' wig. They were obviously Tokio Hotel, the brand-new yet utterly useless German band. Their live performance allowed me to appreciate their new work, titled "Scream" (perhaps because it's the reaction people have when seeing the cover...).

The first thing you notice is definitely the singer, Bill Kaulitz, who, despite all his efforts to prove otherwise, is a boy, moreover without a voice, who manages to be overshadowed even by the least pulsating bass of his friend Georg Listing during the live performance. Moreover, the bushy-haired, highlighted singer is the author of a really clever trick: when the song's note is too high, evidently well aware of his limits, he decides to let the audience sing!

The album, despite the miraculous help of the studio, is horrible, so don't even try to download it, you'd just be wasting your time. Defined by the band itself as emo rock influenced by Motley Crue (for the heavy makeup?), AC/DC (for this blasphemy they deserve public flogging...) and Linkin Park (perhaps the only ones really referenced by the music of the four...), their sound is distinguished by an evident syrupy coating that is occasionally alternated with slightly more decisive moments, immediately nullified by the mellow voice of the screaming hermaphrodite. The symbol of the band's sycophancy are two songs, different from each other, but simply because they are two different sides of the same coin, "Monsoon" and "Break Away". The first is the annoying hit single that delights us at least five times a day on the radio, characterized by a flat and repetitive rhythm, a background guitar that increases (a little, truth be told) in intensity as the refrain approaches. The refrain is the most horrifying part of the song, because where one would expect a high note (or at least something similar... come on, if he doesn't try to scream now that he’s 18, what will he do at 40?) from the singer, the voice rises by half an octave and then retreats timidly. "Break Away" is instead structured on the alternation of empty moments, with only voice and bass, to fuller ones with voice and guitar repeating an insistent loop followed, on the same notes, by the bass, but all this isn't new to me, I wonder why... Ah, maybe because "Black Dog" by Led Zeppelin and "Alive" by Pearl Jam are built in the same way?

In a period where the music of new bands like 30 Seconds To Mars, Interpol, Strokes, Arctic Monkeys & co. is hitting the skids, the four German lads decide to follow suit and quickly end up in oblivion. How sad...

Loading comments  slowly

Summary by Bot

The review harshly criticizes Tokio Hotel's album Scream, focusing on weak vocals by lead singer Bill Kaulitz and unoriginal music. The band’s attempt at emo rock is described as syrupy and redundant, with a live show that fails to impress. Key tracks like 'Monsoon' and 'Break Away' are seen as both repetitive and derivative. Overall, the album is deemed a waste of time despite studio production.

Tracklist Lyrics Videos

02   Ready, Set, Go! (03:34)

Read lyrics

04   Love Is Dead (03:41)

07   Sacred (04:00)

11   Forgotten Children (04:37)

12   By Your Side (04:22)

Read lyrics

Tokio Hotel

Tokio Hotel are a German pop rock band formed in Magdeburg in 2001 by Bill Kaulitz, Tom Kaulitz, Georg Listing and Gustav Schäfer. They broke through with the 2005 single “Durch den Monsun” and debut album “Schrei,” followed by the English-language compilation “Scream.” Later releases include “Humanoid,” “Kings of Suburbia,” and “Dream Machine.”
08 Reviews

Other reviews

By P@ne

 "This band is truly incredible: they convey emotions but also pure adrenaline with songs like 'Scream', 'Monsoon', 'Ready Set Go', and 'Love Is Dead.'"

 "To conclude among the negative notes, I can only point out a slight lack of originality which I hope can be filled with experience and time."


By Dany94

 Tokio Hotel are leading young people to depend on these posers who do nothing but give them a false idea of "rebelliousness".

 "Scream" is a collection of very low-value pop songs... devoid of feeling, written to favor the music business.