Cover of Gentle Giant Octopus
Vituperio

• Versione 1 Rating:

For fans of gentle giant,lovers of progressive rock,music enthusiasts interested in complex instrumentation,listeners who appreciate classic 1970s rock,readers curious about music critique and history
 Share

THE REVIEW

Progressive rock is often defined as a popular sub-genre of music characterized by an unusual rhythmic structure that does not follow the usual rhythmic rules of Pop, Folk, Rock and Roll, or Blues, such as verse-chorus-verse. Rather, it features sudden tempo changes executed in odd time signatures, all supported by a large array of varied instrumentation: keyboards (Hammond), percussion of any kind, transverse flutes, violins, trumpets, metallophones, and more. Although progressive rock aimed to bring a breath of fresh air to popular music in the late sixties, blending influences from Jazz, Symphonic, Classical, and Medieval Opera music. Critics of the era often targeted the grandiose suites of prog's champions, highlighting the excessive technical exuberance that was sometimes an end in itself.

And who can blame them? Indeed, I, Vituperio, despite being a progressive rock lover, cannot deny that albums like "Tales From Topographic Oceans" have the power to bore me to tears (Yes fans, don't take it personally... you know I love you anyway). Perhaps I'm wrong... but the music critique overlooked the fact that, textually speaking, progressive rock songs were making giant (gentle) strides, preferring philosophical themes over social ones, fantasy over the real world, literary works, etc. So a respectable progressive rock band absolutely has to handle these musical characteristics as well. In short, to cut a long story short (as I have gone on too much already), if I had to choose an album that encapsulates all the best features of progressive music without any negative side, without hesitation I'd choose Octopus by Gentle Giant. A milestone.

RATING: 5/5, completely subjective.

Loading comments  slowly

Summary by Bot

The review discusses progressive rock's unique traits, such as irregular rhythms and diverse instrumentation, while highlighting its philosophical lyrical themes. Despite some prog albums being overly complex, Gentle Giant's Octopus stands out as a perfect example of the genre's best qualities. The reviewer awards the album a full 5/5 rating, calling it a progressive rock milestone.

Tracklist Lyrics Videos

01   The Advent of Panurge (04:41)

Read lyrics

02   Raconteur Troubadour (04:01)

Read lyrics

03   A Cry for Everyone (04:03)

Read lyrics

05   The Boys in the Band (04:32)

Read lyrics

06   Dog's Life (03:11)

07   Think of Me With Kindness (03:34)

Gentle Giant

Gentle Giant were an English progressive rock band active from 1970 to 1980, frequently described (in these reviews) as among the genre’s most technically accomplished groups, known for multi-instrumentalism, complex rhythms, and choral counterpoint.
16 Reviews

Other reviews

By panurge

 The extreme intricacy that characterizes the music contained in the album... does NOT compromise the noble and animalistic nature of Music.

 One realizes that the song... rocks. It rocks differently from everything we’ve heard rock before it.