Saputello

As for the album, the personality that permeates it is remarkable, although unfortunately, in my opinion, it is not free from flaws: if it had lasted 30 minutes (I think it lasts more than 50), it would have been a masterpiece; instead, given the number of things they had to say (things of extreme quality), they repeated them, ultimately resulting in redundancy.

Look, in my opinion, this is nothing but a fanciful flight that, instead of clarifying, extracts confused musical considerations and undermines the initial point, which was also a good review in my opinion. It’s true that there is that element of childishness, but the observations that stem from your comment are (especially in the second-to-last paragraph) the apotheosis of the conceptual chaos that you have in your head. "It’s the clash between rational/irrational, childish and programmatic, chaotic and orderly" OR "what the Battles tell is not a solution, but the problem" ---> Passages like these demonstrate that with your rhetorical excesses, you can say everything or the opposite of everything, you can claim that we are fully in progressive, just as easily as you can say that we are not, that we are witnessing a sick evolution of post-rock, as well as its denial.

I didn't really like this review.

Uho! Tastes are tastes, everyone has their own weakness, for example, I really like the Arcade Fire, who are indeed derivative but hide their new wave influences much better, making them almost unrecognizable. Of those I mentioned and you don’t know, make sure to get their best records. It's a shame though about Mark Lanegan; I think he’s really great!

Ah, you were also asking me about poets, I see. Well, even in this case, introducing them into this discussion seems a bit out of place, but still, at least I'll give you one name: Rabindranath Tagore, poet and writer, Indian. Discovered by chance. I really like his poems a lot.

"I'm not asking out of arrogance; I really want to know, so I look for them and see if I like them."-----> "Oh my God, there are tons of them; these questions, thrown out like that, aren't very productive. It's much more fruitful to discover them right here on Debaser. And then there's always the classic response: 'Oh, know-it-all, are these the bands? I downloaded them, tried to listen, and they all suck.' But I still want to mention some: people like Mark Lanegan, Magnetic Fields, Scott Walker (once very famous; now if you ask who he is, people reply 'huh?'), Cat Power... I'm just throwing out the first names that come to mind, but there are so many that it doesn't make sense to list them now in this conversation. Instead, we could mention all the bands that the wave of British young copycats draws heavily from, namely Television, Kinks, Who, Clash, Smiths, etc. Have you listened to those?"

@ Odra: Oh, I didn't even notice, you’re back?? I haven't been hanging around here much anymore.

@ Odra: "Damn, Saputello, really? It's not nice, come on, to wish that on anyone"---------> It's not nice, but it's much worse to see everyone drooling over every crap that this Doherty spits out. Every piece of garbage that regularly gets a meager sufficiency because it has the usual catchy rhythms and makes headlines because there's that lice-infested larva in the mix, so it looks cool, while a ton of real artists making serious music or writing true poetry remain in the shadows. Jesus, what's so original about this music? These libertines, babyshambles, and so on are just a constant copy-paste. For this and a thousand other reasons, I'm preparing to avoid the tracks from the new album like the plague. Even Up the bracket back then made me sick, let alone. But then again, that's just how I am; I also can't stand the interpol, who make music that’s 30 years old and are highly praised. If I want old music, I'll listen to the originals.

Certo! Inviami il testo che desideri tradurre e provvederò a farlo.

Yes, of course, he's a great poet, why not. I bet, by the way, that you've gone through a lot of poets before reaching that conclusion, right? Let's hope he dies soon from an overdose, so they stop cramming his body unnecessarily into recording studios.