puntiniCAZpuntini

I will believe that METAL exists, only METAL where everything goes, when someone explains to me all the common points between Dream Theater and Sunn O))). If they manage to find me the commonalities, then I'll ask them to explain the similarities between any band with Sean Malone and Electric Wizard. Then maybe they'll also explain to me why I, who own tons of records of this infamous METAL, can't stand Iron Maiden while I adore PanterA. And afterwards, they’ll explain why CPTgaio loves Iron Maiden while giving a 3 to this album that, for me, is pure gold. Then, and only then, will I believe that METAL exists. It's not that by speeding up a genre, you get METAL; you just get that genre, sped up. It's not that by slowing down a genre, you get METAL; you just get that genre, slowed down. And speeding up and slowing down are two completely opposite things. Yet, for some, it’s METAL. The most expansive musical genre in the history of music. Practically 70% of the world's population that listens to music would be heavy metal fans. Wow, what intelligent discussions. /////////// PS: it cracks me up to see someone like Yosif, who listens to Rap (like me), criticizing the violent lyrics of Metal. Rap has lyrics millions of times more violent, and often more idiotic too. Damn, the Wu-Tang Clan has been going on for 15 years about how they’re Shaolin, and then if you throw a punch at Method Man, he ends up in the clinic while RZA stays in the lurch and Ghostface Killah remains pregnant (but then, let's note the name: GHOSTFACE KILLAH).

Well, it seems to me an impossible comparison DM vs NIN, I can't find any terms of comparison. I like DM too, but not in an incredible way like I liked Reznor, enough to buy everything possible. As for the lyrics, I insist: once you’ve heard one, you’ve heard them all. Just throw in a Feel (or derivatives like feelin’, felt, etc.), a Lie (and derivatives), a couple of me you us everybody, and choose three paths: the claustrophobic, the angry at the world, and the melancholic. Make three albums and various EPs. He’s one of my favorite artists, but he wrote pretty much the same lyrics all through the 90s. The meanings are always the same, the atmospheres very, very similar. And that’s the beauty of it, because you know what to expect and you enjoy the genius in finding the perfect sound every time.

The fact that Punisher likes it confirms that it's a load of biblical proportions. /// Pretty Hate Machine should have been listened to in '89 maybe; I heard it after Fixed, in '94, and it didn't say anything to me. I bought it for my collection but I never listen to it. I don't even have it on the mp3 disc with the discography I take in the car.

A biblical-sized piece of crap. Reznor has made 10,000 identical lyrics and structurally very simple songs. What set him apart (and continues to set him apart) was the immense beauty of the sounds he offered. I've heard everything, but I've never heard anything produced as well as Reznor from Broken to Things Fall Apart. If you take away the wonder of the sounds, what remains? An unbearable boredom, two balls the size of a house. The only wrong purchase I made from Reznor, along with Pretty Hate Machine. Of course, I don't buy anything from this point on; otherwise, I would have made many more mistakes. To buy this crap, it’s better to get the Maxi Singles, like Closer To God to hear Reznor doing Techno with Memorabilia, or March Of The Pigs to have All The Pigs, All Lined Up, which is a hundred times better than the original version. Or even to get the soundtrack of The Crow, which, besides its nice Joy Division cover, has many other great tracks. In short: buy everything from '91 to 2001 but not this mind-numbing crap.

Zolo Telegraphic Works

<<< The Battisti case... doesn't exist! It's an ingenious trap set by Mr. Berlusconi to gain popularity and distract from real issues. >>> My God, how disgusting. Truly disgusting. If they extradited him on the spot, the news would be over by the end of the day. The point is that Brazil opposes it; that's where it all began. But surely, there are those who think that through Kakà, Ronaldinho & Pato, Berlusconi has made a deal with the Brazilian president to divert our attention. What a clever one. Tell that to the families of the PAC victims that the Battisti case doesn't exist. Tell that to those who fought with all their might against power in the '70s that the Battisti case doesn't exist. ----- The review is nothing short of perfect, balanced, presenting the issue without bias while still delving deep. Thankfully, in Italy, there are not just imbeciles who can't maintain a moderate opinion, and who consider - before speaking - that everything we know is still secondhand news, already chewed over by journalists and politicians. Well done again.

<< I don't see how you (or Wikipedia) can give a precise definition of Drone >> have you ever read in the dictionary what the term DEFINITION means? You're doing an unnecessary mental exercise; I was discussing your statement regarding the common definition of the term Drone in Music. If you come up with "For me, Drone is whipped cream on a state of mind sandwich," what do you want me to say? Fine, for you, Drone is half a rhinoceros omelette, good for you. For the rest of the world, no. Just that. << Morkobot are "a bit" Drone, >> Besides the fact that Morkobot have nothing to do with it, as I was discussing Ufomammut and Lento, it’s one thing to say "they're a bit drone," and another to say: -- the drone of the fellow countrymen Ufomammut and Lento -- because you imply that Lento and Ufomammut are Drone. Furthermore, you say that drone is not a music genre, but rather a state of mind. So, Ufomammut and Lento have never made records, and they're not even musicians, but rather a state of mind. <<< but boredom kills, really >>> Well then go pick some maruzze (wild greens), why add yourself to the tons of bullshit misinformation that infests the internet? It’s disgusting to read all this tons of nonsense (not saying you, I’m talking about the internet in general), everyone states their own crap and those who read it can sometimes take it for granted. Just last week someone at the bar insisted that NIN were Heavy Metal, not derivatives, just Heavy Metal. To my "but how do you deduce that?", he replied, "I read it somewhere." If you don’t enjoy the objective plane, write reviews without technical terms. If you write technical terms, then write them correctly. You can even do a review of Morto talking about Findus Fingers, and no one would say anything.

Beautiful. Craig remains a master, never wrong in his life. Heard him live three times in three different places, and he has always been in tune with everything and everyone.

For me, on the contrary, Drone is one of those words that can't mean a damn thing nor can it be a musical genre with clear boundaries. But what does it mean, for me? It's a definition, period. So, for me, jazz is a musical genre that combines congas played at 4000 bpm and the sounds of sheet metal crashing against walls of whipped cream. What I’ve written about drone is its definition known to most, and it’s the same one listed on Wikipedia (which writes a mountain of nonsense about music, the value of opinions being less than zero). Definitions have only one purpose: to make clear what music someone produces, and if you put Morkobot in Drone, you send that someone off the rails. On the "three records" of beginning and end, it’s like that. Because there are only the Drone-Doom "records" of "bands," which is what Drone means. There are no bands of Australian folk music that only use the didgeridoo (AND THANKFULLY!), so if you say Drone, it’s normal to mean Dilan Carson & Stephen O'Malley. Then, well, if we start with the "for me," this site loses 80% of its meaning, which is to articulate how a record sounds. <<< I took a look at other reviews of “MoRtO” and those fucking synthesizers have been noticed by others too. It's not an excuse, but damn, those three idiots have fooled everyone! :) >>> Indeed, there are plenty of 15-year-old idiots out there with 3000 downloaded records and not a single one bought, reading about instruments, all listened to halfway through, and they even write reviews. I pointed out this thing about the Synthesizer, because that word is now used to define any possible electronic effect, even "Synths" are no longer the instruments but the sounds produced. A Synthesizer (a serious one) is an instrument, and quite complicated. By defining any little button on a groove box or any PC software as a Synth, you belittle those who really know how to operate that instrument. It's not that you become Schulze by buying a Mac, eh. The Mac always sounds the same, it’s a file; the Synth, on the other hand, is a wonderful instrument. And the Morkobot don’t have it, nor do they know how to play it.

<< drone (which is not a musical genre with precise limits). >> For me, instead, it is one of the very few ultra-definable musical genres with its boundaries. No melody, 95% of the time no drums, no vocals, nothing at all. Just distortions with basses at two thousand. If not, it’s not Drone. In fact, it’s a genre that started and ended in three albums. How can you say that Earth are similar to Ufomammut? How can you like Earth and loathe Sunn O)))? It doesn’t make sense; it’s the exact same stuff spat out precisely. Being the peak of minimalism, you can’t really find differences between one and the other. Unless you mean Earth from 2000 onward. And if you mean from 2000 onward, you’re still wrong, because then you’re not talking about Drone. Sunn O))) have always made drone (in fact, they've been annoying us for a while now). Ufomammut have vocals, drums, rhythms, notes, electronic effects, riffs, rich prizes, and cotillion... how can it be Drone? <<< misled by the fact that the album is packed with synth lines, >>> No, not at all. But do you even know what a synthesizer is? Now I can show you one, because that about the synthesizer is very serious. This is a synthesizer -> <- For me, they don’t have one. I’ve never seen them live, but I’ve never heard synths in their albums. Now I can show you one :)