Antonino91

In my opinion, it may lack what has been presented in How the West Was Won, that is, the magnificence.

I'll tell you how things really are: I 5, II 5, III 5, IV 5, houses of the holy 5, physical graffiti 4, presence 3, 5, in through the out door 3, coda 3, 5.
P.S. the live the song remains the same: 4 or 5 (I've never been so uncertain) long live led :-D

I would like to add one thing: it's a pity there are no half values, otherwise I would have given it a 3.5.

The four Englishmen couldn't have made a better debut than this... but I don't agree with the review. There is no connection with the Beatles; I admit that some songs have certain pop melodies, but that doesn't mean you have to compare "Matilda Mother" to "Sgt. Pepper"... Anyway, great album.

You are fools... You can't compare the film The Wall to Live at Pompeii, because they are two completely different things: Live at Pompeii is an exciting show, The Wall is a beautiful film. However, regarding the album, I believe it is a masterpiece just like all the others (half a step below Animals). As for the review, I commend the reviewer: I have never seen better reviews. Well done, Charles.

In this album, the Led reveal their sweet and folk side, but that doesn't mean the album is to be thrown away! For me, it’s a masterpiece, maybe not as good as IV, but it’s still a masterpiece. Great job, Led, you have made us dream and will continue to do so (I have to tell my friends who listen to crap music this). Regarding the review: Luciano, I’m satisfied because yours is a review I respect and that largely carries truth.

In my opinion, better than Dark Side. I would define it as 100% progressive rock rather than symphonic rock or psychedelic rock. If Pink Floyd wanted to create something completely different from The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, A Saucerful of Secrets, and Ummagumma (maybe even More), they fully succeeded in their intent.
The title track is fantastic: 24 minutes of true progressive music. "If" is a beautiful ballad with a magnificent electric guitar solo by Sir David, "Summer 68" is magnificent and melancholic, and "Fat Old Sun" showcases Gilmour's guitar genius at its best. Finally, what remains, in my opinion, the pinnacle of this album and one of the most successful examples of schizophrenic collage: "Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast." Beautiful and mind-blowing, especially the third part.
Honor to Waters, Wright, Gilmour, Mason, and of course to the mastermind Syd.

Regarding Claudio's review, I won't take anything away from it: it's a beautiful review, like all the others. Moving on to the album: here we are faced with an extraordinary masterpiece (for me, however, Animals is better), although some aspects of this album could be avoided (some sax parts). Now let's talk about the strengths of this album: Breathe, Time, Brain Damage, and Eclipse are, for me, the true masterpieces of this record. Then Speak to Me—I couldn't even discuss it (I don't consider it a song, I see it as a simple but splendid, practically mad intro). Being just an intro, The Great Gig in the Sky is a pleasant ballad with Clare Torry's breathtaking ups and downs. The same goes for Any Colour You Like: enjoyable, but nothing more. As for Money and Us and Them, I'll say this: they're not bad, but they seem a bit repetitive and perhaps slightly out of context. Anyway, this album is definitely not bad; it remains a masterpiece. It should absolutely be added to the list of albums you haven't purchased yet.

I am the one who wrote this review.

PuntiniCAZpuntini, I don't exactly agree with you.
What do you think matters in a group, physical appearance or the music?
Let me give you an example. The blues are liked only because they're trendy; in fact, their music holds little to no value.
Anyway, regarding the review of this splendid album, I agree with you.
Led Zeppelin I is a great album.
Long live the Zeppelin forever!