Alevox

ahaha great review

Great review...I'll try to check out the album.

The usefulness of reviewing greatest hits is impressive... but when it comes to reviewing a greatest hits that even rocks know, it's even more so.

Great review, but I would have liked a more "decisive" judgment on this triple. It's unclear whether it's something interesting for hardcore fans or if it's a complete nonsense... because from what I'm reading, there are quite a few doubts about the usefulness of this new release.

Good album, but overrated. I never understood what "Sweet Lady," "I'm in Love with My Car," "Death on Two Legs," and "The Prophet's Song" (tedious beyond measure) had to do with anything...really pointless tracks that ruin the beautiful opera-like atmosphere (sometimes almost cabaret) that is otherwise perfectly evoked at certain moments. It could have been the ultimate glam album, but it wasn't.

Certo, invia pure il testo e procederò con la traduzione.

A fitting review for an album of such importance.

Well, shaky review... it feels like a middle school essay, too many personal details.

finally, some serious albums are being reviewed...

An atypical review. To be harsh, it could be outright dismissed solely for the unnecessary initial premise (I believe no one is interested in knowing why you are reviewing a work, where you found it, what needs to be reviewed and what doesn't... this is something I strongly advise you to eliminate from your future works). On the other hand, the completeness of the essay is commendable, where you provide the plot of the film and a brief profile of the director (perhaps there wasn't a need for a background on Antonioni, but it never hurts). The choice of the "decalogue" is debatable; it seems more a matter of convenience than style since a review is not a shopping list, and the skill of the reviewer lies in synthesizing and tying together many elements into a single text. There is some content, but the text is riddled with clichés and erroneous reasoning ("it seems absurd to me that to interpret something I see, I have to go read what others think about the story I've seen, it means the message isn't getting across"... it implies that film critiques are pointless and we should all be learned) which ultimately forces me - with regret - to dismiss it.