sentence

Well, I won't reread the whole novel you posted, but I'll just say that I don't agree with primiballi even a little (and who cares, the people will say). The fact is that "wish you were here" can become tiresome over time, "animals" too, but "the piper" and the other albums not so much, at least for me. Not to mention the great sonic innovation brought by certain albums inspired by Barrett (like "ummagumma" and "a saucerful") and also "the piper"; these are the albums that revolutionized music, and they are the same ones that inevitably led to more relaxed, complete, and calm works, even if at times more banal, like "wish you were here" and "animals." Barrett is god, and I don't say it because I feel compelled to. "Wish You Were Here" gets tiring after a while, while "Piper" much less so. Even if this is a subjective evaluation...

you, in your brain, you have sawdust.

Sure! Please provide the text you would like me to translate.

it may not be musically at the levels of the band’s psychedelic era, but emotionally it stands as one of the absolute peaks for both the band and rock music as a whole. anyone who disagrees can suck it. but with heart. come on you raver, you seer of visions, come on you panter, you piper, you prisoner and shine!

shine on you crazy diamond

I will definitely have given it.

I pass by here after months and want to clarify that I didn't leave the pirla/anonymous comment. Regardless, I don't like labeling artists like Smith. I'm referring to defining them as 'saved by pop.' But I understand what you mean; it was indeed the enormous creativity expressed by the Cure in those years that made them last. However, I wouldn’t define Pornography as an exception to their style, which, in my opinion, it belongs to. For me, it's beautiful because it's essential, repetitive, anguished, in simple words, conceptual. I believe it's perfect in its context. But that's just my personal opinion! Maybe I said a bunch of nonsense, but that's not a problem.

more useless than a duplicate

what a load of crap to keep saying that 'if this is worth five then sgt. pepper', 'if this is worth five then dark side of the moon', 'if this is worth five then mozart', just fuck off. every album has different criteria for judgment, the historical context, the careers of the authors, etc. and every album needs its own rating without pointless fucking comparisons.