donnie darko

Sacerful of Secret is a great album for its time, but for me, for example, it doesn't come close to Sgt. Pepper, it doesn't have anything to do with it. In fact, I much prefer the latter. So? J Jefferson Airplane, tell me, besides the niche audience, who remembers them? I listened to them, but they didn't grab me. And who will remain in history? None of those you mentioned. Furthermore, to help you understand the importance of the Beatles, tell me any other band that has been dead for 30 years that releases an album and goes straight to number one in the charts worldwide? Only they can do that; a band that is still so loved today simply doesn't exist! A group that will remain in history, a bunch of losers? I don't think so. And maybe consider other people's opinions more; don't label them as bullshit just because they differ from yours.

Look, I’m almost 50 years old and my tastes can’t be the same as yours, clearly. Your argument makes sense, and I can't tell you my opinion since I haven’t listened to these records (considering how much older I am than you, I say records, not CDs :-) You have every right to say that this album sucks, and I will never criticize you for that, but saying that the Beatles are overrated is a historical falsehood. I can understand your disdain for Sgt. Pepper, but the Beatles started playing in '58. Listen to the music from those years and tell me if they didn’t change it.
I’m throwing down a challenge: give me some titles of these CDs that would be better than Electric Arguments, and I (who listen to everything) will share my thoughts. For example, how many of you know Medusa's Spite? I'm their number one fan, and they are almost unknown—just to show you that I don’t only listen to the Beatles. And anyway, for alternative music, ask Primi.

But excuse me, where’s the problem? Primiball said he liked the album and thinks it’s better than many other albums released. That’s his opinion, where’s the issue? It’s you who has prejudices and thinks that music is only what you listen to, but it’s not like that. There are so many musical genres precisely because tastes are different. Paul McCartney and the Beatles overrated? Are you kidding?

Are you kidding me, jil? One or two what?

I have short hair, so no braids. My comment that got you annoyed was about one of your comments on my review. If you’re not joking, I’d be happy to be your friend.

And why are they kicking you off FB too? What did you do?

Of course, Jil, I am the most peaceful person in this world. :-)
We just have different opinions, that's all!

Yes, jil, you are right. I don’t waste time with those who only offend without any arguments. What was resentful in my comment? And instead, tell us which albums you’ve listened to; we are curious too.

Look, I didn't say it's better than other albums, nor that it's a masterpiece of modern music; he himself said he was afraid he might have dared too much. I only say that, if what he said is true, and given how it was made, it's a nice album that I listen to with pleasure and will buy. The fact that at 65 he still has the desire to play, in my opinion, speaks in his favor, but I am actually not objective since I love everything about The Beatles and the individual members.
But still, it outshines many of today's artists :-)
Hi.

Well done, that’s exactly the point, it has been coming since 1962. The rest is just talk. I listened to the record again, it’s beautiful, no doubt about it!