Edoardo Bennato: Sono Solo Canzonette
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
Another excellent album, well above "Uffà! Uffà!" from the same year; perhaps the second-to-last gasp of the best Edo. The title track and "L'isola che non c'è" are the most successful pieces. 4.5 rounded up to 5 out of affection.
  • Martello
    18 jun 20
    "An affection is not felt, it is worn directly." It would deserve a full 5 just for L'isola che non c'è and the title track.
  • Kism
    18 jun 20
    What Italy! At that moment, Edoardo was at his peak; his texts were even being studied in schools.
Edoardo Bennato: OK Italia
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
It's the last album by Edo that I really liked.. I would give it a 7.5.
Edoardo Bennato: La Torre di Babele
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
The latest album by Bennato is more “raw” and “angry.” Beautiful, although I slightly prefer the two previous ones and the following one. 4.5
Edoardo Bennato: Burattino Senza Fili
Vinile I have it ★★★★★
It's the album by Edo that I love the most, just after "Io che non sono l'imperatore." Wonderful.
Excellent debut work. Musically speaking, it might still be a bit raw, but it's incredibly inspired nonetheless. "Un giorno credi" is my favorite of the entire repertoire, but "Una settimana, un giorno," "Campi Flegrei," the title track, and "Tempo sprecato" are also wonderful. Rating 4.5
Edoardo Bennato: I Buoni e i Cattivi
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
This is truly, truly beautiful. Second only to the emperor as far as I'm concerned... 5 full.
I listened to it again yesterday, and it undoubtedly ranks in the top 3 of the worst of the worst of Edone. Besides being unnecessarily hyper-long, it alternates between "simply" bad tracks and truly embarrassing ones. Second only to "Sbandato" as far as I'm concerned. 1 star broken.
  • Martello
    24 aug 20
    And what's the third one? The ways of rock? Or the girls?
  • Ditta
    24 aug 20
    Obviously "The ways of rock...". Next up is "The girls..."
Edoardo Bennato: Sbandato
CD Audio I have it ★
And I'm good!
It seems like an attempt to replicate what was done in the 70s. Obviously, a failed attempt. I would only salvage a few ideas... for the rest, the downward trend continues sadly. I would give it a 1.5, which I round up.
Edoardo Bennato: E' arrivato un bastimento
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
Great album, probably the last of Edo's golden era, although the next two are still enjoyable. 4 stars.
  • Kism
    7 may 20
    At the time of its release, it was a big disappointment, uninspired, poorly sold, and similar in outcome to Lucio Dalla's contemporary 1983. Three years to produce it, big names involved, yet the result is "nobody remembers it" and it diminished the career of an artist who in 1980 filled San Siro.
  • Turbitt
    28 sep 20
    Great work that deserves to be re-evaluated highly. I agree with you, Ditta: the last real good job from Edo's "important" period. Kaiwanna is already inferior, although not to be underestimated. There are really eclectic and varied atmospheres and solutions here, with truly fitting arrangements. The contributions with the saxophone are truly remarkable.
  • Ditta
    28 sep 20
    I save Edo until "Abbi dubbi" from '89, after that he becomes terribly hard to digest. However, I confirm that EDOARDO BENNATO (deliberately in uppercase) ends here...
After a few scattered glimpses of decency in the previous two works and the extraordinary last-minute effort “È asciuto pazzo o padrone,” comes this truly terrible album that irrevocably brings poor Edo to the same artistic level as Ramazzotti and Antonacci. He will never rise again.
  • Martello
    8 jul 20
    A bit ugly, huh? But due to its genesis, it has always reminded me of Jannacci's Discogreve; the matrix is the same, but the result... no. 5/10, with little woodworms attached trying to nibble an extra half-point.
  • Ditta
    8 jul 20
    How magnanimous you are; for me, this is no more than a 3.5/4 (out of 10). And yet, he would manage to surpass himself three years later with "Sbandato."
  • Martello
    8 jul 20
    What the hell was SBANDATOH?! 4! 4!! Compared to that, the girls dreaming is a De André album, I’m serious!
  • Ditta
    8 jul 20
    "What the hell was SBANDATOH?!" A load of crap. Colossal.
  • Martello
    8 jul 20
    It's sad to know that SBANDATOH is from the same year as several masterpieces like Gommalacca or La morte dei miracoli. In the series: how a black sheep manages to hide among the white ones.
"Have doubts" was still enough, but this is where the slaughter truly begins. Following this, there will be a handful of albums, each uglier than the last ("Sbandato" being the worst). Much better is the contemporary "È asciuto pazzo 'o padrone," released as Joe Sarnataro. I would give it 1.5... let’s say 2.
  • GustavoTanz
    26 jun 23
    More than 2 than 1. But there are three excellent tracks: "Lo Zio Fantastico," "Martiri Del Rock'n Roll," and "Tutto Sbagliato Baby," which makes me want to cry, so much so that even Mia Martini made it her own some time later.
Edoardo Bennato: Uffà! Uffà!
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
The first signs of yielding, but at the same time still a more than decent record, even though the previous one and the following one are clearly superior to me. 4 fair stars.
Edoardo Bennato: Kaiwanna
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
Overall, a good album, although it obviously doesn't even come close to his masterpieces. Probably Bennato's penultimate work, fully inspired. Almost 4.
Edoardo Bennato & the fair of shit, part 3. The previous two parts were taken from the unspeakable piles of garbage from 1998 and 2003. And let’s remember that this is still the same guy who sang “Io che non sono l'imperatore”…
Edoardo Bennato: Pronti a Salpare
CD Audio I have it ★★★
Re-evaluated, nothing particularly shocking but still a "bearable" album. Clearly better than all the other albums of the last thirty years. 6/6.5
  • Martello
    5 sep 20
    I agree, strangely decent. In the autumn, he should be releasing a new one...let's see what he has come up with this time.
Enzo Jannacci: Parlare con i limoni
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
One of the less beautiful ones by Enzo, but anything below 4 isn't worth it.
  • Martello
    12 jun 20
    For me, it’s really only worth three stars and that’s it. It disappointed me quite a bit, mainly because of some tracks that are arranged and sometimes written really poorly. Anyway, if you really have the CD of this album, I have to respect you because it’s not at all easy to find this CD, really well done.
  • Ditta
    12 jun 20
    I tried to evaluate it not only by comparing it to his discography but also to that of his "colleagues." For example, I personally don't find it to be on the same level as "Abbi dubbi," "Bugie," "Un uomo in blues," "In questo mondo di ladri," "Good-bye Indiana," "Nove" (all of which I think are at a 3), nor on the same level as the various "Burattino senza fili," "Come è profondo il mare," "Nero a metà," "Lilly," "La pianta del tè," "Agnese dolce Agnese," etc. (all rated 5). It stands (again, in my opinion) on par with the various "È arrivato un bastimento," "Viaggi organizzati" (here you probably won't agree), "Ferryboat," "Buona domenica," "700 giorni," "Viaggi e intemperie." I hope I'm making myself clear.
  • Ditta
    12 jun 20
    Anyway, yes, I have the original CD; I found it in the early 2000s at a second-hand stall, and I didn't let it slip away...
  • Martello
    12 jun 20
    Aside from the fact that Enzo is quite an unusual singer-songwriter, it’s really tough for me to say whether Parlare con i limoni is on par with works like Buona domenica or Viaggi e intemperie: they all have songs that are really well written as usual (the title track for Jannacci, Firenze for Graziani, and Modena for Venditti) and tracks that are a bit of a mess, like La fine della storia or Kriminal.
  • Martello
    16 jun 20
    @[Company] could you send me the tracks from the CD of parlare con i limoni? Many tracks I've downloaded from that album have completely distorted audio. Thank you.
  • Ditta
    16 jun 20
    Unfortunately, my computer doesn't have a CD drive... when I have access to one, I'll let you know and I'll send them to you.
  • Martello
    16 jun 20
    Thank you anyway
Fabrizio De André: Rimini
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
By far the album by Faber that convinces me the least, and still deserves a 4 (which in reality would be a 4.5).
Fabrizio De André: Tutti morimmo a stento
Vinile I have it ★★★★★
Among the top 10-15 albums of Italian music. Perfect album.
  • Martello
    3 may 20
    I can't deny its value, but as far as I'm concerned, it's still very immature.
  • Ditta
    3 may 20
    Let's say that those of this period are a bit sleepy; from "La buona novella" onward, it will completely change course, also thanks to excellent collaborations (I immediately think of Mauro Pagani in "Creuza de ma" and Ivano Fossati in "Anime salve").
Fabrizio De André: Storia Di Un Impiegato
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
Magnificent album, perhaps underrated. "They Will Ask You About Our Love," "The Bomber," "Song of May" but above all "The Father's Song" I consider the most successful tracks.
Fabrizio De André: Canzoni
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
Among De André's less beautiful albums, but with a handful of stunning gems ("La ballata dell'amore cieco," "Canzone dell'amore perduto," "Fila la lana"...).
  • Martello
    15 may 20
    I would also add Via della povertà and La città vecchia. And yes, it is one of the less beautiful ones by Faber.
Fabrizio De André: Creuza De Ma
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
Faber's masterpiece (possibly alongside "Anime salve"), hats off. It deserves 6 stars.
Fabrizio De André: Anime Salve
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
Simply wonderful, probably his most successful album (along with the masterpiece "Creuza de ma"). A thank you also goes to the collaborator Ivano Fossati.
Among Faber's top five works, and among the first 25-30 records of Italian singer-songwriter music. Beautiful, perhaps his peak from the seventies (it's on par with the previous one).
FRANCESCO DE GREGORI: Canzoni d'amore
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
Musically speaking, for me it is his peak: an excellent album, arranged wonderfully. Eleven truly inspired tracks, and, 28 years later, still relevant, including "Tutto più chiaro che qui," "Bellamore," and "Sangue su sangue," and especially "Rumore di niente." Rating 4.5, almost 5.
  • Martello
    22 jun 20
    And Adelante Adelante! It’s the first song by Degre that I fully appreciated, ever since I was a little kid.
Francesco De Gregori: Viva L'Italia
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
Surely an excellent album, still relevant after all these years, with gems like the title track or "Capo d'Africa," but honestly, I find it significantly inferior to all the previous ones and the 2 that followed. However, as a rating, a solid 4.5 fits perfectly.
  • Martello
    12 may 20
    The rating is a bit too high. I think a 4.5 should be given to albums like Titanic or AL LIMITE by De Gregori; for Viva l'Italia, I would give it a solid 4. It's a good album, but definitely inferior to the previous and subsequent ones up to Terra di nessuno. Nevertheless, it's an album that is masterfully arranged, yet has some missteps like Stella stellina, which doesn't place it on the same level as his masterpieces.
  • Ditta
    12 may 20
    "De Gregori 78," just like "Titanic," is a solid 5 stars for me. I consider it to be roughly on the same level as "Scacchi e tarocchi" or "Terra di nessuno."
  • Martello
    12 may 20
    It's hard to judge Scacchi e tarocchi: it's not a bad album, but the decline in inspiration is noticeable. If I really have to give it a score, I'd say a 7.5, because it has some nice tracks, but, like Viva l'Italia, it also has unnecessary falls. P.S. I hope I'm not the only one who finds Poeti per l'estate fantastic.
  • Martello
    12 may 20
    *In the first sentence, I lost a pronoun.
  • Ditta
    12 may 20
    "Chess and Tarot" is indeed slightly inferior to the subsequent one. However, it had some splendid tracks, in addition to "La storia," which we all know by now, I would add "A pà" (every time I listen to it, it deeply moves me). Then, other intense pieces like "Miracolo a Venezia," "Ciao ciao," the title track, "I cowboys," or, indeed, "Poeti per l'estate." "Sotto le stelle del Messico a trapanar" and "Piccoli dolori" are indeed two lesser tracks, but still enjoyable.
  • Martello
    12 may 20
    Chess and Tarot might be the worst of the 70s and 80s (not counting Miramare, of course). It may seem vulgar, but I've always referred to Chess and Tarot as "an interrupted coioto."
  • MarkRChandar
    28 jan 21
    For me, however, this is the most anonymous of all De Gregori's albums, I've never liked it that much. I prefer "Scacchi e tarocchi" where you've already highlighted the best songs.
Francesco De Gregori: Miramare 19.04.1989
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
In my opinion, this is a nice album. Perhaps the arrangements are a bit too "exaggerated," so to speak, but the tracks themselves are truly beautiful: especially "Bambini venite parvulos," "Cose," and "300.000.000 di topi." However, staying within the "neighborhood," I prefer the previous one.
It's nice to see artists who, after 50, are still able to produce excellent work. Great album, but in the 2000s I find "Amore nel pomeriggio," "Pezzi," and "Per brevità chiamato artista" on a slightly higher level. Rating: 4 right balls.
Francesco De Gregori: Bufalo Bill
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
In my opinion, this is the best album by the Prince (after "La pecora" and on par with "Rimmel"). It's really hard to dismiss anything. Simply wonderful.
  • Kism
    19 jul 20
    I totally agree with your judgment. It's my favorite album by the Prince. I bought it by chance in a supermarket, and it accompanied me throughout the trip. Later, I delved deeper by also buying "Rimmel," which I call "Buffalo Bill"; for me, it's his definitive album. It takes you far away with its lyrics and stories. The music is beautiful as well.
Francesco De Gregori: Scacchi E Tarocchi
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
If you look for the Prince of "Rimmel," "Bufalo Bill," etc., you might end up a bit disappointed. However, if you listen without preconceptions, it remains an excellent album, featuring gems like "La storia" and "A pà."
Francesco De Gregori: Alice Non Lo Sa
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
A grand debut for the prince, clearly better than the previous "split" with Venditti. So poetic, yet at the same time so hermetic. Aside from the title track, which we all know well, there are other wonderful pieces like "Le strade di lei," "Saigon," "Buonanotte fratello," and "Marianna al bivio." Rating 9.
Francesco De Gregori: Rimmel
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
Absolute masterpiece, with indissoluble gems like the title track, "Pezzi di vetro," "Pablo," and above all "Le storie di ieri." However, for my personal taste, I slightly prefer "La pecora."
  • Martello
    5 may 20
    The best by De Gregori for me. It’s only behind Terra di nessuno. Then La pecora is fantastic (Informazioni di Vincent keeps blowing my mind).
  • Ditta
    5 may 20
    As far as I'm concerned, I would say:
    1. The sheep
    2. Buffalo Bill/Rimmel
    3. Alice doesn't know
    4. De Gregori 78
    5. Titanic
  • Ditta
    5 may 20
    Let's say this is "THE" album par excellence of the Prince (just as "La voce del padrone" is for Battiato, "Come è profondo il mare" for Dalla, "Sotto il segno dei pesci" for Venditti, "Il mio canto libero" for Battisti, "Pigro" for Graziani, and so on).
Francesco De Gregori: Francesco De Gregori
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
And for me, this is absolutely the best album by the Prince, slightly above the next one; so poetic, so minimal, so melancholic. It’s absurd that the same author today repudiates it as if nothing happened. "Bene" is probably his greatest masterpiece; it’s impossible not to be moved. "And you can still call me my love.."
Francesco De Gregori: De Gregori
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
Undoubtedly the most heartfelt and soul-searching album of his entire discography, although (in my personal taste) I consider it slightly inferior to the previous four, while at the same time definitely superior to the following "Viva l'Italia."
  • Martello
    11 may 20
    It is a fact that it is superior to Viva l'Italia and inferior to the three previous ones; it is the one that resonates the most, yes, but in my opinion, it is not the one he suffered the most for. In this regard, it only ranks behind Terra di nessuno for me.
  • Ditta
    11 may 20
    True, "No Man's Land" was also very heartfelt. Perhaps on par.
Francesco De Gregori: Titanic
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
As far as I'm concerned, De Gregori's penultimate album is a masterpiece. Its peak marked in the 80s (along with the subsequent EP), containing wonderful gems: in addition to the more well-known title track, "Caterina" and "La leva calcistica...", also "Belli capelli" and the (alas) forgotten "San Lorenzo". A full 5.
  • Martello
    14 may 20
    Caterina is the first one I met and the one that left the strongest impression on me. Perhaps because when I was in school, there was this Caterina who was known for having a spine-chilling voice. Too many memories.
Francesco De Gregori: La Donna Cannone
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
Probably the last great masterpiece of the Prince (before "Love in the Afternoon" in 2001). "La donna cannone" is undoubtedly a beautiful song, but nowadays, I am more touched by "La ragazza e la miniera" and especially "Canta canta."
Francesco De Gregori: Terra di Nessuno
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
Underrated work, but excellent as far as I'm concerned. The best of the 85-89 trilogy, with arrangements that aren't too pompous (unlike the subsequent one) and no filler tracks (unlike the previous one). "I matti," "Mimì sarà," and "Pane e castagne" are the standout tracks. 4.5
  • Martello
    7 may 20
    The madmen are perhaps one of the last gasps of the Better Prince. Then the rest, magnificent. War pilot takes me elsewhere every time.
  • Ditta
    8 may 20
    As far as I'm concerned, in all the albums there are at least 2-3 gems worthy of the best from the author (with the exception of the very latest ones).
Francesco De Gregori: Prendere e Lasciare
CD Audio I have it ★★★★
Of the Prince from the 90s, I prefer "Love Songs," but this is also an excellent album. "A Glove" is simply extraordinary. Rating: 8
Francesco De Gregori: Amore nel Pomeriggio
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
The best Prince album from the 2000s: a truly beautiful record with equally stunning gems. "Il cuoco di Salò" is probably De Gregori's best track from the last thirty years (along with "Un guanto" from the previous album).
Francesco Guccini: Via Paolo Fabbri 43
CD Audio I have it ★★★★★
"The Poisoned," "Almost a Love Song," and "The Retiree," oh dear.