Survivor 12

I know they are heavily criticized. I don't mind them, I'm being honest, and I really like this album.

I've never really liked them in general, not even in the 90s with Dookie, but this one grabbed me quite a bit; there was urgency, great tracks, and two "suites" that broadened their musical approach, which otherwise was really too limited. It's a pity they didn't follow up with something equally interesting.

what a nightmare the singles from this shit album...

Ugly! :)

First love is never forgotten!

Beautiful beautiful

The album I wore out back in middle school, and it remains alongside "Dookie" the only one of theirs that I still like.

Beautiful like a hemorrhoidal thrombosis.

The pragmatics of Silas is worth framing.

Aside from the usual high-snob comments, it's an excellent pop-semi-rock album. The kind that was packaged well in the '80s. We can say that Green Day made two or three singles and this album, and that's it. But this remains an album to remember (in pop history). I've always seen it as a sort of new and modern Grease! A pop musical.

Aside from the fact that Gris really sucks to me, I still need to understand why this album can't disgust me without being considered some alt-snob and other random words thrown around by someone who often speaks randomly. Let me get this straight, Gì, you say it’s good, so fine, otherwise you’re just a fucking alt-snob. Very, very logical.

a great semi-rock pop album but also somewhat semi-brutal.

Yes, it's logical. It's logical because your comment comes after mine and therefore it certainly cannot refer to it, don’t you think? Also, I didn't say that this album is great in an absolute sense (that would be going too far) but I contextualized my judgment, just as I didn’t say that anyone who says this album "sucks" is an alt-snob. With words and concepts, we need to be precise. I "speak at random" a whole lot of crap.

"Aside from the usual alt-snob-de-sto-gran-cazzo comments" Which ones?

I swear I know you are right, I’m probably a snobdistograncazzo. I get chills listening to it. I feel out of place.

The comment "alt-snob-de-sto-gran-cazzo" is not your typical remark that simply states "I hate this album," which is, of course, a legitimate opinion. Nor is it "it gives me chills to listen to it," an equally valid comment that describes a mood and physical reactions to listening to an album. No, the comment alt-snob-de-sto-gran-cazzo doesn't fall into any of these categories: it essentially refers to the attempt to ridicule both the album and, consequently, anyone daring enough to listen to it or to give it even a mildly positive judgment, often using hyperboles that are usually associated with a loud laugh or sports banter. In short, the alt-snob-de-sto-gran-cazzo comment is usually as lovely and intelligent as a kidney stone the size of a ripe "cuore di bue" tomato (e.g., an alt-snob-de-sto-gran-cazzo).

Those who criticize them, however, I can tell you are not really sorry for you! :-P

Don't be upset, after all, we are right!

..I feel sorry for those who listen to them.. ;;)

This five little balls are taken regardless of what comes after.

When it comes to taste, it's all subjective, but at this point, let's give 5 stars to the greatest hits of my family's karaoke anyway...

It's not that I give 5 stars to every album, I consider this the best album by Green Day and the best Pop Punk album FOR ME.

But I was saying to Taurus.