FrenkyWestSide

DeRank ™: 0,39 • DeAge™ : 4239 days

Love
  • Contact
  • Here since 17 december 2013
Roger Waters: The Pros And Cons Of Hitch - Hiking
CD Audio I have it ★★★
Roger Waters: The Pros And Cons Of Hitch - Hiking
6 jun 14
The musical continuity of The Wall and Final Cut... the first two stand strong... this one doesn't. Sorry Roger
  • GIANLUIGI67
    7 jun 14
    a shameful cover, perhaps as much as the album itself. Even "Radio Kaos" was indecent. As a teenager, I was obsessed with Pink Floyd, but today I wonder why; "The Wall" is a heavy-handed work on the verge of tastefulness, and the last thing I like is "Echoes."
  • madcat
    7 jun 14
    A typically Pink Floyd cover.
  • ZannaB
    9 jun 14
    Let's say that over the years he has become increasingly pompous; for me, the peak (of pomposity) was reached with Amused to Death, but The Wall is still worthy of attention. Let it be clear, attention, not compliments.
  • templare
    9 jun 14
    Loquacious.....
  • perfect element
    27 jun 15
    Just for Clapton's guitar, it deserves the highest score. Secondly, Waters is loved and cannot be debated. Amused To Death represents his solo peak and is not at all pompous; it is a masterpiece, considering the lineup of guest artists.
  • ZannaB
    29 jun 15
    I consider a masterpiece based on the compositions, not on who performed them. An album can be pompous and a masterpiece at the same time. For me, however, Amused to Death is just pompous, not a masterpiece. That doesn’t mean it’s bad, it just means it’s pompous.
  • ZannaB
    29 jun 15
    Is it clear that I find it pompous? If not, I’ll say it again...
  • perfect element
    22 aug 16
    Just the three parts of 'what God wants' would be enough to annihilate anyone; one must not confuse the search for the perfect sound with pomposity.
  • ZannaB
    22 aug 16
    Damn Perfect, but after how many years did you finally reply???
    For me, Amused was and remains a pompous hodgepodge, just like The Wall: both contain beautiful tracks (see What God Wants) but both drown in a sea of self-referentiality and pretentiousness.
    "Look at me, I'm Waters, I'm good and I'm cool," okay, but come on, enough already...
  • perfect element
    22 aug 16
    It continues to move me in its entirety, pardon the timing.
  • ZannaB
    22 aug 16
    Of course, I don't expect others to agree with my opinion. If it moves you, I understand why and I'm happy for you; even though I find it pretentious, we're certainly not talking about cheap trivial music...
Similar users
FLOYDMAN

DeRank™: 0,24

mauro60

DeRank™: 0,23

mantaray

DeRank™: 0,04

franc'O'brain

DeRank™: 0,14

hjhhjij

DeRank™: 15,27

nes

DeRank™: 19,87

JURIX

DeRank™: 18,52

extro91

DeRank™: 7,10

Belghazi

DeRank™: 1,83

TheNoiseIBreath

DeRank™: 2,32

Tags 1/1
#maibanali