tonysoprano Banned

Your comment on the chart

Comments on this chart

• 

  SalvaDM

  3 sep 16

  Great ranking, of course 20 is very few. But I can't stomach shopping lists. However, for me, the top spot goes to Astral Weeks, then Rock Bottom ;)

   

  •  Love (00)
  •  Hate (00)
  • (11)
  • (11)
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    They are 20 just to avoid making long lists with too many names. It’s a matter of taste. I love them both absolutely, but the way I love RB is too profound. The heart cannot be commanded.
  • 

    SalvaDM

    3 sep 16

    Of course... it's almost impossible to choose between two albums like that.
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    It doesn’t make much sense to create rankings with so many names; it tends to devalue artists who don’t deserve to be devalued. Better this way, at least for me.
  • 

    SalvaDM

    3 sep 16

    One note: from you, a fan of Hammill, I expected one of his solo albums in the charts ;)
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    Think that before re-listening to RB, AW was my favorite album. It took me a long time to find an album that I liked more...
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    If you want Hammill's records, you'll find him in the singer-songwriter rankings.
  • 

    SalvaDM

    3 sep 16

    Ah okok ;)
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    Added the good Peter :)
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    I stop at 30, that's enough, or else it gets too rich.
  • 

    SalvaDM

    3 sep 16

    Great for Peter and of course for the Slint _
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    I often listen to Spiderland, especially Washer.
• 

  Mr. Money87

  3 sep 16

  Very beautiful, in my opinion it's missing a few names, but overall we're good. And, well, for me, if Morphine are in a ranking, it's already a great ranking.

   

  •  Love (00)
  •  Hate (00)
  • (04)
  • (04)
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    In fact, my choice to include only 20 names is due to the desire to avoid creating a ranking filled with names.
  • 

    Mr. Money87

    3 sep 16

    If you're featuring singer-songwriters, you can't miss Pink Moon!
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    It's predominantly rock; I've never seen Pink Moon as a rock album.
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    for this reason, a great name like Leonard Cohen is also missing
• 

  IlConte

  3 sep 16

  I'm sorry, but these rankings are a farce on the level of "best" this and that from Rolling Stone. How can you compare Buckley, I don't know, Black Sabbath, Neil Young, and Deep Purple?? Come on, guys, don't stoop to this nonsense!!!

   

  •  Love (00)
  •  Hate (00)
  • (05)
  • (05)
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    They are just preferences. I certainly don’t want to spark debates about whether X is better than Y.
  • 

    IlConte

    3 sep 16

    Sure, but emotions can't be classified. I love Deep Purple and Van Morrison, who have nothing to do with each other. Should I prefer one?! They both move me in different ways. Anyway, don't worry, I hate the uselessness of these rankings because I could name 50 artists that resonate with me, but I don't want to, and I wouldn't know how to choose...
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    I mention only 30, to avoid turning it into a stew of different albums.
  • 

    tonysoprano

    3 sep 16

    I create these rankings only for myself. Because if one day I were to distance myself from rock, I would have a reference to start over. Or, if I were to lose my memory, I would have these albums in this ranking to guide me back to what I love.
  • 

    IlConte

    3 sep 16

    Ah ah ah losing memory what a blast go with the Rock god boy!