TheJargonKing

DeRank ™: 16,68 • DeAge™ : 6427 days

Love
  • Contact
  • Here since 15 october 2007
Best Drum and Bass artist of all time
qui metterò i migliori drum (1- 30) e i migliori bass (31 - 60), prevalentemente progressive e jazz rock in ordine un po' così ..., anche qui alcuni che avrei messo, mancano. Ad esempio il miglior italiano di sempre Furio Chirico.
Your comment on the chart
Comments on this chart
  • sellami
    sellami
    25 jul 10
    Yes, but drum and bass is a whole other thing.
     
  • Claypool
    Claypool
    25 jul 10
    I agree with Bruford in first place, but PHIL COLLINS SECOND? Ahead of people like Colaiuta, Bozzio, Peart, Cobham? For me, that just doesn't exist.
     
  • TheJargonKing
    TheJargonKing
    25 jul 10
    @sellami: I know that drum&bass is something else, but I wanted to make this ranking and didn’t know where to put it.
    @Claypool: It's always up for debate to place Collins high, but I have followed his technique for years and I assure you it’s imaginative, complex, and personal like few others. A couple of years ago, I spoke with Gregg Bendiam, the drummer who reformed Mahavishnu and is currently with the cover band Nusical Box. He is an exceptional drummer, and he also confirmed to me the great difficulty in picking up Collins' scores due to some of his personal and unique characteristics.
     
  • Claypool
    Claypool
    25 jul 10
    I never said that Collins is a hack, on the contrary, he must surely be a creative drummer, but from my ignorant perspective, I see other drummers as superior; I mean, Cobham is from another world in my opinion. This could also be influenced by some biases I have against Collins (let’s just say I don’t really like him), but people like the aforementioned Billy or Neil Peart are true human drum machines ("Spectrum" and Rush docet).
     
  • teenagelobotomy
    teenagelobotomy
    25 jul 10
    Nice ranking, much better these than those of real drum and bass :). I'm not an expert in technique, but I think the first place is deserved. Personally, I really appreciate Phil Rudd's simple style. But I would also include Chris Layton, and for Italy, I would have chosen Tullio. Cheers.
     
  • panNZZOone
    panNZZOone
    25 jul 10
    Well, for me, Neil Peart is unbeatable in rock (one could say he would masterfully play fusion too) and Steve Gadd is indispensable.
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    25 jul 10
    Bruford is still Bruford...
     
  • panNZZOone
    panNZZOone
    25 jul 10
    No Di Cioccio doesn't say anything to me.
     
  • McEnroe
    McEnroe
    31 jan 11
    In my opinion, Phil Collins is overrated; compared to other rock legends, he’s almost a banal hitmaker. To each their own, though…
     
  • McEnroe
    McEnroe
    31 jan 11
    oops, they are not in order
     
  • Stefano90
    Stefano90
    31 jan 11
    In the bassists, I would have included (high) Les Claypool (Primus) and Mark Sandman (Morphine). There, I said it!
     
  • scaruffoditurno
    scaruffoditurno
    31 jan 11
    What the heck, this ranking literally made me jump as soon as I saw the super-grandISSIMO unbeatable & monstrous Bruford in the first seat (I fully agree!), but then at number 2, I wonder what the heck a washing machine salesman ("PHILCO") has to do with it. Maximum respect for the attribution criteria, for goodness' sake, but with all due respect... I don't know?!?
     
  • progknight94
    progknight94
    3 apr 11
    And Evans, isn't he good, Evans?
     
Similar users
DaveJonGilmour

DeRank™: 1,09

cofras

DeRank™: 12,76

killgod

DeRank™: 0,05

CoolOras

DeRank™: 2,91

Bisius

DeRank™: 2,26

JpLoyRow

DeRank™: 2,10

TelespallaBob77

DeAge 6598

Kenny.Club

DeRank™: 0,00

NickGhostDrake

DeRank™: 4,46

alessioIRIDE

DeRank™: 3,14

Tags 4/4
# #01 #2 #che
Groups
Proggarolo Comindeb
Rewards
week 37 - 2011
week 48 - 2011
week 11 - 2017
Gran Visir -la recensione