Train Of Thought is an album that says a couple of things overall:
1. The theatre of dreams is now old
2. Despite this, the members have improved with age like a good wine
3. You either hate them or love them
The recording quality is as perfect as usual, as we’ve been accustomed to having from DT for some time. The songs are the right length despite the usual mammoth durations typical of DT, and in some moments, one must admit the skill in creating certain touching or at least well-structured moments, but the ideas are now exhausted..
There are many plagiarisms of song parts from bands of our days or the now past (see Metallica, Pantera, and Tool, above all), and by now the musicians' exhibitionism has become something abstract on the album; in fact, Petrucci's solos are indeed very fast but lack pathos and sometimes really seem like a sort of declaration of the type "listen how fast I go... I am the best!"
On the positive side, it's worth highlighting that LaBrie, thanks also surely to the composition of the pieces, feels more at ease and finally sings properly without falling into phrases that were barely understood in the past.
Stream of Consciousness: 11 minutes of pure music that enter forcibly into Dream Theater’s history.
The album closes with 'In the Name of God,' probably the most beautiful song on the album, where indeed all the members give their best.
It's simply fantastic, it mesmerized the audience upon its release, they have once again shown themselves to be out-of-this-world!
DT are superior to everyone and Train of Thought is one of the many demonstrations they have presented and will hopefully continue to do for years and years to come.
Everyone’s entitled to their tastes—but veteran fans disowning the band baffles me.
'Stream Of Consciousness' is the most beautiful track on the entire album.
If the New York band had distinguished itself for originality and versatility, we now face blurred imitations of Tool and Korn.
The album, while showcasing some valid episodes, proves to be a low blow for longtime fans but could attract a new audience.
"With 'Vacant' I feel the real Dream Theater: truly beautiful and touching... melancholic and even heartbreaking."
"Train of Thought falls into the 'trap' of metal, with too many solos and high rhythms... absolutely not their style."