Cover of Smashing Pumpkins Zeitgeist
Deviljin

• Rating:

For fans of smashing pumpkins, alternative rock lovers, readers interested in music critiques and band reunions
 Share

THE REVIEW

I begin by saying that I have never been a staunch fan of the band in question, but I have still greatly appreciated some albums (among which Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness surely stands out, which I still consider among the essential albums of the 90s) and I was very curious to listen to this "Zeitgeist", considering the reunion after nearly 7 years of absence.
I was very skeptical about the quality of the album, given Corgan's latest indecent projects, but after reading a positive review I thought: "Well, they're still the Smashing Pumpkins; even if the album isn't great, there will always be three or four interesting songs, let's give it a try." Unfortunately, I had placed too much trust in this historic band because this "Zeitgeist" is the most inane, monotonous, and fake thing I've listened to in years. Not a single song was worth saving!!!!!

From the opener "Doomsday clock" to the concluding "Pomp and Circumstances", it is a torture for the poor ears of the listener; a voice made even more camp than it was by fey choruses scattered here and there like parsley throughout the album and on top of that, buzzing guitars overdubbed 3000 times to create a psychedelic effect. Better for you to go farming, dear Smashing Pumpkins, if you're short on cash, rather than fool all your fans. It's pointless to fill an album with thousands of effects and some guitar licks if the songs aren't there, don't exist, and it's like listening to nothing for over an hour, not a single idea or damn brilliant riff that gives you chills. What happened to songs like "Zero" or "Bullet with Butterfly Wings"? The Smashing Pumpkins of yesteryear aren't even a shadow of what they were, and it just bothers me to see all these bands that no longer have anything musically to say and reunite only out of hunger, having burned all the billions they had on experimental drugs we can't even imagine. When a band reunites after 7 years, I repeat 7 years of absence, one might think what kind of genius they have concocted to come back so suddenly, but unfortunately, it's all business, no one thinks about the ears of the poor unsuspecting listeners who will listen to this crap, deluded into thinking they are facing one of the year's albums. It just makes me cry thinking about how many excellent bands in the world, busting their butts to write songs with a capital S, don't even have a budget contract with an independent label, while labels still give room to these four money-driven idiots who think of everything except creating a product with a soul, but unfortunately the Smashing Pumpkins, despite producing crap albums, guarantee a certain number of copies to a record label, an emerging group does not.

Anyway, this is a strong candidate for the golden palm for trash of the year, I doubt another album will be able to surpass it, though never say never ever.

Loading comments  slowly

Summary by Bot

The reviewer approaches Zeitgeist with skepticism due to past disappointments with Billy Corgan's projects. Despite hoping for a few redeeming tracks, they find the album monotonous and lacking true songs. The production is criticized for excessive effects without substance. The review expresses disappointment in the band's decline and condemns the reunion as a commercial move rather than a creative one.

Tracklist Lyrics

01   Doomsday Clock (03:44)

Read lyrics

02   7 Shades of Black (03:17)

Read lyrics

03   Bleeding the Orchid (04:03)

Read lyrics

04   That's the Way (My Love Is) (03:48)

07   United States (09:52)

Read lyrics

09   Death From Above (04:06)

Read lyrics

10   Bring the Light (03:40)

11   (Come On) Let's Go! (03:19)

12   For God and Country (04:24)

13   Pomp and Circumstances (04:20)

Read lyrics

The Smashing Pumpkins

American alternative rock band formed in Chicago and led by Billy Corgan, famed for 1990s albums such as Siamese Dream and Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness.
50 Reviews

Other reviews

By MiciaTigre

 This new one is ugly, gaudy, overly produced with five hundred overdubbed guitars, a plastic production that induces nausea.

 The pumpkins ended after the release of the beautiful 'Adore', the rest is not Smashing Pumpkins.


By fastfish

 Corgan seems to have run out of ideas and wanting to continue being a rocker for who knows what reasons...

 Everything seems perfectly polished without particularly salient moments, it’s all a mash of old rock tricks as old as my grandma.


By zaireeka

 After the fourth/fifth listen, you’ll realize it’s not like that, and even tracks such as "Doomsday", "Pomp and Circumstances"... can ultimately be counted among the best things by SP.

 "United States", the most "extreme" track... will make you feel like you’re on vacation in Iraq, in the midst of a cheerful bombing.


By billyburke

 "The beginning is overwhelming, 'Doomsday Clock' grows with each listen, with a dark riff and apocalyptic lyrics."

 "'Bleeding the Orchid' is, in my opinion, the masterpiece of the entire album, embodying the soul of the best Smashing Pumpkins."


By Torre Ste

 "United States is a sonic punch that raises the quality of this return by one of the groups that marked the '90s."

 "The noisy, raw, distorted sound is different from previous albums, disappointing some old fans while trying to find a new audience."