•
Rating:
THE REVIEW
When discussing this album, there isn't much debate over the tracks because they are and will be a piece of musical history, irrespective of which version is released. Instinctively, however, it is compared to its brother: the magnificent album that in 1969 the Beatles recorded and disowned but was published in 1970, the last one that brought down the curtain on the fab four's fantastic decade-long career.
In this “Let It Be,” the much-talked-about changes are actually few and in a few tracks; the arrangement has changed: this seems recorded in a garage with just voice, guitar, bass, drums, and piano; there's no interference from the producer (or murderer?) Phil Spector, who weighed down the previous version; although maybe that wasn't a bad thing: after all, all those strings, brass, and those celestial choruses made this album (or rather, that one) a milestone in the world's rock scene. The fact is, this is certainly sparse but fascinating; it feels like listening to demos: just listen to "The Long And Winding Road," "Across The Universe," or "Let It Be" before and after the treatment, and you'll understand the chasm that separates the two versions. The tracklist has changed, but that's not a big deal since (as we were taught in elementary school) changing the order of factors doesn't change the result; those insignificant interludes like 'Dig It' and 'Maggie Mae' have rightly been removed, and "Don't Let Me Down," a ballad that blends well into the content of the new version, has been added instead.
In conclusion, this album sounds a bit more rock than the old one but ultimately doesn’t add anything new to what we already knew about the Beatles, and apart from the changes made to the aforementioned tracks, the rest is the same; in short, it seems more like yet another speculation at the expense of the fans of a historical band rather than an album kept hidden in Paul McCartney's drawer. P.S. The rating is not at all related to the quality of the product, which is unparalleled, but to the real usefulness of this CD.
Loading comments slowly
Summary by Bot
The review examines The Beatles' Let It Be... Naked as a stripped-down alternative to the original 1970 release. It highlights the raw, garage-like sound and less production interference by Phil Spector. Although some tracks were rearranged or removed, the album doesn't add much new to the Beatles' legacy. The reviewer sees it more as a fan curiosity than a groundbreaking release.
The Beatles
The Beatles were a British band formed in Liverpool in 1960 by John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison and, from 1962, Ringo Starr. They revolutionized popular music through songwriting, studio innovation and cultural impact, releasing landmark albums from Rubber Soul and Revolver to Sgt. Pepper’s, the White Album and Abbey Road before disbanding in 1970.173 Reviews
Other reviews
By Hal
"We are facing yet another marketing operation."
"Regarding the Beatles, what they represented, their history, Let It Be dressed says much more than naked."
By fosca
Let it be remains a masterpiece, but in its original, tormented and dressed version.
These post-mortem exhumations leave me a feeling of coldness and speculation, nothing more.
By cece65
Finally, Sir Paul has done himself justice.
"The Long And Winding Road" with only Paul’s piano and Ringo’s drums is even more magical than the original.
