Discipline, King Crimson 1980
"Discipline is never an end in itself, only a means to an end."
King Crimson, after the magnificent and very sad farewell of Red in 1974, returned at the dawn of the '80s with a totally renewed and revised formula, free from labels and reference points.
The only confirmed member was Bruford (technically more terrifying than ever), joined by two virtuoso American musicians: Adrian Belew (rhythm guitar) and Tony Levin (Chapman Stick and bass).
Naturally, all the instrumentalists revolved around the stern master Robert Fripp, who, in his impeccable English style, did not fail to amaze all audiences and especially the critics.
What Fripp and Bruford wanted to create was something new and totally uncontrollable, allowing free expression to the two contrasting sides of the brilliant guitarist: absolute artistic rigor and total madness, with the addition of cohesion, a cohesion between instruments that had never been heard before, not only in terms of sound mixture but especially in the ability to naturally accommodate the virtuosic outbursts of their companions (as demonstrated by the track "The Sheltering Sky").
The album opens with the biting "Elephant Talk" dominated by Belew's distorted guitar simulating elephant trumpets and sounds of a decidedly unorthodox nature. The song best reflects the most brilliant and creative soul of KC, always in search of the future and innovation, always saddened by the stagnant present. A very interesting track from different perspectives, starting from the lyrical one: for the first time KC let themselves go in a song, albeit dripping with irony and satire, full of sense of humor and cheerfulness, elements absolutely unusual for the British band. Bruford's drumming perfectly outlines his African style, which precisely originates from Fripp and co.'s primal intention to draw inspiration from the hypnotic rhythms of Gamelan, African dance, creating Gamelan Rock.
However, the virtuosity of this new incarnation of KC resides in the second song, the (technically) terrifying "Frame By Frame", which distinctly gives the impression of coming from a future era.
Fripp supports Belew's genuine guitar bursts with absurd speed, Levin accompanies with an elementary but fearsomely incisive bass, joining Bruford's fresh and irregular drumming with jazzy ease, all the way to the sad refrain, where Belew recites a Japanese Haiku with a plaintive voice and the tension is discharged with powerful bass drum hits supported by timpani blows of African might, along with the rest of the instruments that resume the initial theme at their usual speeds. A continuous alternation of full and empty that forms a truly timeless song. Noteworthy is the authentic feat performed by the two guitars at the refrain's reprise, where one of the two keeps the rhythm normally and the other replicates it by missing a single note each time, but magically the guitars find themselves in sync at the sixteenth repeat of the measure.
Next is "Matte Kudasai", a slow, sweet, and romantic piece not particularly remarkable, although truly emblematic of Robert's ability to infuse emotions, even before claustrophobia and aversion in abundance.
The track proceeds with a magnificent full/empty alternation until the final apex, dominated by a total unleashing of instruments in an irregular 13/8, which can only remind us of the immortal Starless... The dark side of discipline, indiscipline "I LIKE IT!" as Belew’s final scream declares.
Follows the exciting and very fast "Thela Hun Ginjeet", which narrates with a real-time recording an experience undergone by Fripp and Belew in New York, where they encountered a gang. The piece is performed at high speeds and partly anticipates the style that will belong to U2.
Following is perhaps my absolute favorite track. "The Sheltering Sky" is the album's long song, tense between dreamlike vibrations and pure frippian math-rock. Spectacular and reflective, yet at the same time intimate and tormented, rich in combined breaks of the two guitars on the soft Stick carpet of dear old Levin. But the most spectacular thing about this song is its layering. After hundreds of listens, I think I can affirm that never has Fripp written a piece so complex and yet seemingly so simple. It's an 8 minute and 24-second dialogue between all instruments, no more, no less, first Levin converses with Belew, then he reports to Fripp what was said, then Fripp bursts into a monologue towards the end acclaimed by Belew, who joins his guitar in the chorus. Listen to believe.
Next is "Discipline", the album's most "classic" track, based exclusively on the magnificent dialogue of the two guitars, the crazy and more pronounced improvisational ability of these KC, cold and mathematical yet so boiling over with creativity.
In the bonus edition, there is another version of Matte Kudasai more rocking, which then to be honest is completely a new track of a style almost similar to Rush's, really beautiful and lively. I know this review has already been written, but I would have liked to leave my opinion on my favorite album. Go easy on me, I'm only 14 years old xD
Tracklist Lyrics Samples and Videos
01 Elephant Talk (04:42)
Talk, it's only talk
Arguments, agreements, advice, answers,
Articulate announcements
It's only talk
Talk, it's only talk
Babble, burble, banter, bicker bicker bicker
Brouhaha, balderdash, ballyhoo
It's only talk
Back talk
Talk talk talk, it's only talk
Comments, cliches, commentary, controversy
Chatter, chit-chat, chit-chat, chit-chat,
Conversation, contradiction, criticism
It's only talk
Cheap talk
Talk, talk, it's only talk
Debates, discussions
These are words with a D this time
Dialog, duologue, diatribe,
Dissention, declamation
Double talk, double talk
Talk, talk, it's all talk
Too much talk
Small talk
Talk that trash
Expressions, editorials, explanations, exclamations, exaggerations
It's all talk
Elephant talk? Elephant talk? Elephant talk!
02 Frame by Frame (05:10)
Frame by frame (Suddenly)
Death by drowning (from within)
In your, in your analysis.
Step by step (Suddenly)
Doubt by numbers (from within)
In your, in your analysis.
03 Matte Kudasai (03:48)
Still, by the window pane
Pain, like the rain that's falling
She waits in the air
Matte Kudasai
She sleeps in a chair
In her sad America
When, when was the night so long
Long, like the notes I'm sending
She waits in the air
Matte Kudasai
She sleeps in a chair
In her sad America
04 Indiscipline (04:33)
I do remember one thing.
It took hours and hours but..
by the time I was done with it,
I was so involved, I didn't know what to think.
I carried it around with me for days and days..
playing little games
like not looking at it for a whole day
and then.. looking at it.
to see if I still liked it.
I did.
I repeat myself when under stress.
I repeat myself when under stress.
I repeat myself when under stress.
I repeat myself when under stress.
I repeat..
The more I look at it,
the more I like it.
I do think it's good.
The fact is..
no matter how closely I study it,
no matter how I take it apart,
no matter how I break it down,
It remains consistant.
I wish you were here to see it.
I like it.
05 Thela Hun Ginjeet (06:26)
Thela hun ginjeet thela hun ginjeet
Qua tari mei thela hun ginjeet
Qua tari mei heat in the jungle street
"Well, first of all,
I couldn't even see his face.
I couldn't see his face.
He was holding a gun in his hand.
Umm... I was thinking...
This is a dangerous place..
This is a dangerous place.."
Thela hun ginjeet thela hun ginjeet.
Qua tari mei thela hun ginjeet.
Qua tari mei heat in the jungle street.
I said, "I'm nervous as hell from this stuff.
I thought those guys were going to kill me for sure.
They ganged up on me like that.
I couldn't believe it.
Look, I'm still shakin'.
Weird.
There out in the streets like that.
It's a dangerous place.
It's a dangerous place."
So, suddenly, these two guys appear in front of me.
They stopped.
Real aggressive.
Start at me, you know.
"What's that?" "What's that on that tape?"
"What do you got there?"
I said, "huh?"
They said, "What are you talking into that for?"
I said, "It's just a tape, you know"
"Well play it for me"
I said "oh, no"
I put it off as long as I could.
And finally they turned it on, you know
They grabbed it from me.
Took it away from me.
Turned it on.
And it said, "He held a gun in his hand. This is a dangerous place."
They said, "What dangerous place?" "What gun?" "You're a policeman!"
And the deeper I talked, the worse I got into it.
I talked, I told him... I said, "Look man, I'm not talkin'...."
It went on forever.
Anyway, I finally unbuttoned my shirt, and said,
"look, look... I'm in this band, you know, I'm in this band you know,
and we're makin' a recording, you know.
It's about New York City, it's about crime in the streets..."
The explanation was going nowhere, but,
Finally, they just kinda let me go, I don't know why.
So I walk around the corner,
and I'm like shakin' like a leaf,
and I thought, "This is a dangerous place once again, you know."
Who should appear, but two policeman.
Loading comments slowly
Other reviews
By Egli
Personally, I still cannot, after about 2 years of listening, figure out what genre the album belongs to (other than rock, of course), but it’s still excellent.
An album, in short, maybe not exactly a masterpiece, but definitely a beautiful and recommendable one (in my opinion).
By Elephantalk
The relationship is based on the interaction between guitars, which takes the form of: dialogic network, "Call and Response" dialogues, overlaps, and recordings.
"Frame By Frame" is, in my opinion, the most beautiful piece on the album; it starts immediately with a guitar dialogue.
By Emme.
The new sound perfectly blends progressive rock with the strong New Wave influence of those years.
"Discipline" was not only important in the context it was found but also gained value for the strong influence it gave in the future.
By Caspasian
The discipline necessary to train for the "jump," and the work is necessarily rigorous.
He gives and demands deep involvement... "let's dissolve in the shadow..."