Girls
Broken Dreams Club EP

THE REVIEW

Bewilderment, that's what the Girls provoke in me. The critics praised their debut last year, leaving me baffled in front of what was a truly mediocre album, dominated by a lackluster rock 'n roll. I honestly don't understand what appeals to those who appreciate this band.

Thank heaven this EP somewhat diverges from the debut's sound. The Girls have set aside the dull happy days atmospheres to move on to the tender time of the apples.

“Thee oh so Protective” is a more than pleasant slow track enhanced by trumpets.

“Heartbreaker” also flirts with romanticism, a bit Belle & Sebastian, a bit Smiths.

The ballad that gives the EP its title is the highlight. The country guitars and the voice dominate a roots pilgrim-like landscape, very similar to that of bands like Yo La Tengo, with a formidable muted trumpet solo.

“Alright” adds Santana's Latin soul to the group's formula, resulting in inconsistency.

“Substance” is so cloying that it would bring even the rodeo's flies crashing down.

“Carolina” reprises the melody of “Hellhole Ratface” (a song from the first album) and improves it.

Nothing special this EP, although much more appreciable than the debut. It also consists mostly of songs that don't stand the test of time, deflating with each listen.