•
Rating:
THE REVIEW
By deciding to release a double album, an artist takes on a significant responsibility: the risk is to end up being either too boastful or boring by stringing together songs that are either too heterogeneous or, conversely, too similar to each other (the latter flaw being common among bands presenting genres with a low degree of originality).
These are flaws the Foo's attempt to avoid by releasing an electric and rather aggressive first CD, and a second acoustic and intimate one. The fireworks begin with "In Your Honor", a crescendo of redundant guitars and screamed in classic Grohl-style: the song progresses with a finale marked by a superb guitar outburst. More canonically fighter-esque is "No Way Back", initially chosen as the first single, only to be set aside for "Best Of You", which also crescendos and features an excellent bridge built on Dave's frantic drum passages (the house specialty). Scrolling through the tracklist among various fillers ("D.O.A.", "The Last Song", "End Over End") and frankly bland songs ("The Deepest Blues Are Black"), if not downright unattractive ("Hell"), we uncover a gem like "Resolve", a beautiful ballad revealing Grohl's original pseudo-British influence (as he has declared, and furthermore marked by a live execution of "Lyla" by the Gallagher bros). The electric part, in conclusion, is frankly a partial disappointment.
Things improve significantly on the second disc, opened by the beautiful "Still", one of the most pleasant and interesting songs by the American group. Moving on, "Miracle" stands out, which could have even been a single, and, sung by the star-spangled banner's drummer, "Cold Day In The Sun" (smells like Thrills from a mile away). Additionally, there are a couple of noteworthy collaborations: the prodigy Norah Jones in "Virginia Moon" (jazz-flavor aplenty) which features a duet with the ex-Nirvana member (always better than the Valium Williams/Kidman duet), and John Paul Jones, who plays the piano in the aforementioned "Miracle".
All things considered, for fans of the band, it can certainly be said that this is the Foo Fighters' most intriguing work, but for casual listeners, it may turn out to be at times boring and inconclusive (although, as mentioned, Grohl still manages to deliver some good numbers). Better than the dreadful "There Is Nothing Left To Lose" and the stretched "One By One", but light years away from that gem known as "The Colour And The Shape."
Loading comments slowly
Summary by Bot
The Foo Fighters’ double album In Your Honor delivers a bold mix of aggressive electric rock and intimate acoustic songs. While the electric disc feels inconsistent with some fillers and bland tracks, the acoustic disc shines with memorable melodies and notable collaborations. Fans may find it the band’s most intriguing effort, though casual listeners might experience boredom or inconclusiveness. Overall, it’s an improvement over some previous efforts but doesn’t surpass their classic The Colour And The Shape.Tracklist Lyrics Videos
Foo Fighters
American rock band formed by Dave Grohl in 1994 after his time in Nirvana; known for blending alternative rock and post-grunge and for large-scale live shows.32 Reviews
Other reviews
By katzenjammer
In Your Honor unfortunately belongs to that category of albums called 'Silence Covers' and not to the 'Creates Emotions' category.
The memorable songs from the Foo Fighters are Breakout, Learn To Fly, The One, All My Life, and Times Like These... However, In Your Honor lacks its standout song.
By ste84
In Your Honor 2 must be listened to when you are alone, alone with yourself, alone with your thoughts...
This album helps you move forward, isolating you from the rot that plagues this shitty world and is plaguing you too.
