DaveJonGilmour

DeRank ™: 1,09

DeAge™ : 7257 days • Here since 29 july 2006

Love Contact

Guns N' Roses Appetite For Destruction

16 dec 06

Voto:

"The new horizons of nu metal" coming soon on Telenorba

The Beatles Abbey Road

16 dec 06

Voto:

For me, the merit lies in being well-stretched and never tiring or boring, and discussing it adequately is more an objective matter than a subjective one. The flute phrases are well placed and not scattered here and there. The groups you mention are undoubtedly more technical, but it's pointless to compare the contents of two types of prog that are at opposite ends.

The Beatles Abbey Road

16 dec 06

Voto:

Sure, we can debate whether or not they are 100% prog, but I really don't think they are overrated. Plus, it doesn't make sense to compare such different types of prog... What do they have to do with Canterbury? And why would "Thick as a Brick" be a joke?

The Beatles Abbey Road

16 dec 06

Voto:

And then you only mention the technically and compositionally best groups? And the myriad of worse groups??

The Beatles Abbey Road

16 dec 06

Voto:

Overrated? And based on what do you say that? Only 3 albums by Jethro Tull truly belong to the progressive scene as such, of which 2 (Aqualung and Thick as a Brick) are really excellent and not overrated by anyone (especially the latter), and one album, A Passion Play, has always faced harsh criticism. The term "overrated" does not fit Jethro Tull at all.