Shine

DeRank ™: 1,83

DeAge™ : 7454 days • Here since 12 january 2006

Love Contact

Yes Magnification

19 jun 06

Voto:

I'm listening to the soundtrack of Twin Peaks... inspiration rises with every listen! What do you have in the works?

I've thought about it a bit... the review does its job, there's no reason to write another one. I just didn't like the sentences I mentioned above. I'm sorry if I was a bit aggressive. By the way, I also agree with the rating of the album...

Yes Magnification

17 jun 06

Voto:

"There are no covers from the past on the album, all new tracks."
"There are some interludes. A bit like a thriller theme. Not very engaging and serious."
"Alan White hits hard."
The quoted phrases show a certain lack of effort in writing the review.
I’m sorry, but the review seems to be written in haste and doesn't capture the great atmosphere of the album. I do not agree with the editors' choice to place it in the "A series" nor with the ratings from other de baseriani for the reasons I’ve outlined.

Derek Sherinian Inertia

16 jun 06

Voto:

votes

Derek Sherinian Inertia

16 jun 06

Voto:

Interesting and balanced review. However, you could return some love to Saputello...

Dream Theater Live In Tokyo/5 Years in A Livetime (DVD)

15 jun 06

Voto:

I fully share Zarathustra's comments. And I am glad that a constructive criticism like Saputello's has finally arrived, allowing us to finally talk about facts... Everything is relative anyway: the Dream Theater seem very dynamic and varied to me, even if they're bound to patterns that they study almost on paper... it's normal that it is so, otherwise the various members of the band would get lost. Surely, there are even more dynamic bands with a better sense of improvisation than the Dream... They are technically excellent but not transcendent!

David Gilmour On An Island

15 jun 06

Voto:

Sorry, a record might not be to your liking, but you need to articulate your reasons WELL; otherwise, you’re just commenting on the NUMEROUS reviews of this album. Even from a polemical standpoint, I find the review very poor, I would say DISINTERESTED. If you’re going to make a polemic, you either do it well (as Punisher almost always does) or you don’t do it at all. P.S. I'm also waiting for Floydman’s barbs...

Metallica Live at "Rock am Ring 2006"

13 jun 06

Voto:

For the band's enthusiasts: Did Lars Ulrich really participate in the composition of all the tracks written so far by Metallica, or does Hetfield grant him those credits because he founded the band with him?

Tool 10.000 Days

13 jun 06

Voto:

votes

Tool 10.000 Days

13 jun 06

Voto:

I genuinely appreciate such detailed reviews. If the topic doesn't interest me, I move on, but if it catches my attention, I prefer to have plenty of information. Someone had complained about my review of Yes's "Tales from Topographic Oceans," but you have far surpassed me. The only point I can make is that you describe the album in an ecstatic way without managing to offer even a single critique. I understand it’s just a matter of taste, but you seem too much "on their side."