Alfredo

DeRank ™: 6,73

DeAge™ : 7457 days • Here since 9 january 2006

Carnival Of Carnage Carnival Of Carnage / Byocist - Split

16 feb 10

Voto:

That's why, dlf, I don't listen to as much metal as I used to. :DD..to be honest, I still listen to it, but I'm no longer one-track-minded like I was when I was 16.

The Congos Heart Of The Congos

16 feb 10

Voto:

I listened to quite a bit of reggae years ago, thanks to passionate friends: I have come to the conclusion that, except when it's blended with other genres more suited to my ears, reggae is not my cup of tea.

Carnival Of Carnage Carnival Of Carnage / Byocist - Split

16 feb 10

Voto:

The first example that came to my mind when you said "amelodic and dissonant" was the early Sonic Youth. Then I didn't understand: is metal revolutionary because it hasn't evolved at all???

Carnival Of Carnage Carnival Of Carnage / Byocist - Split

16 feb 10

Voto:

"dissonances, noise, and the effective absence of a melodic line that are certainly no more 'musical'">> here I disagree. It's not about musicality; many bands that play amelodic and dissonant music are artistically very relevant. Goregrind bands, I must say, no.

Carnival Of Carnage Carnival Of Carnage / Byocist - Split

16 feb 10

Voto:

I don't know if there are limitations to what can (or can't) be defined as music. I mean, can Merzbow's electronic noise be considered music?

Carnival Of Carnage Carnival Of Carnage / Byocist - Split

16 feb 10

Voto:

@Jargon: formally, this is music. From a critical point of view, I find it tough. I believe it is more of a divertissement even for those who play it. Of course, enduring 77 minutes of "putrid and always the same grind" is tough, I would say impossible if you're not a fan. :D

Allan Grant Marilyn Monroe

15 feb 10

Voto:

@Geenoo: are you serious? the history of cinema?? icon? star?..probably just the right woman at the right time. Became an "icon" and a "star" for what the hell kind of merits then?..she was liked by men. Oh well, eh well, then I won't speak anymore...for God's sakeeeeeeeeee!

Allan Grant Marilyn Monroe

15 feb 10

Voto:

Giola, I was exclusively referring to your comment number 12. I understood the intent of your review, which is excellent by the way.

Allan Grant Marilyn Monroe

15 feb 10

Voto:

@Giola: honestly, I don't see many differences between a Monroe and a Rodriguez, except for the aura of myth that surrounds the former. What can Belen do??..ok, nothing, but what did Monroe, apart from singing horribly and acting poorly, know how to do? the seductress?..same stuff, but different eras. But life was better when things were worse..:D