TheSilentMan

DeRank ™: 0,05

DeAge™ : 8138 days • Here since 27 february 2004

Metallica Live Sh*t: Binge & Purge

12 mar 04

Voto:

This time I have to say that the review could have been significantly better... you overlooked too many things in my opinion, such as the quality of the concert, the lineup, the video quality, etc. etc. The autobiographical story is nice, but a bit too repetitive... What a shame...

KoRn Take A Look In The Mirror

12 mar 04

Voto:

Wow, if my reviews were spit, what is this, a booger??
well...

The Cure Pornography

9 mar 04

Voto:

As for the review concerning the album and the journey it takes the listener on, it deserves a 5 (also for the skill in writing and finding ways to convey emotions). However, it’s a pity that it hardly mentions anything about the band... when the album was released... how it was recorded, and so many other things that I think shouldn't be so easily overlooked...

Elio e le Storie Tese Cicciput

9 mar 04

Voto:

GREAT ALBUM..GREAT REVIEW..GREAT IKO...I completely agree with what you wrote in your review..but come on, you could have at least given this album a 4 after all the praise you've showered on the band..or not?

The Beatles Let It Be... Naked

9 mar 04

Voto:

Great review...excellently written...nice arguments...you know what you're doing...well done!

Lemon Jelly Lost Horizons

9 mar 04

Voto:

Ahaha... and then I would be the nerd???
Instead of calling me a nerd, how about you write a review... I've done plenty of quick reviews (and only out of haste, not incompetence or as a test) but then I did two reviews (trapeze and derek sherinian) that I recommend you go read and then reassess your judgment of me... maybe the nerd here is you and not me...

See you soon

Nirvana MTV Unplugged In New York

9 mar 04

Voto:

Mr. Kurt didn't know much about using his instrument... in fact, he treated it poorly... he punished it... let's just say he knew what sounds he wanted to come out, and somehow he managed to get it done... anyway, the album is not bad, and I think the review perfectly describes what Nirvana wanted to convey... so it's a 5...
Anyway, I agree with those who say you should review other bands... come on, too obsessed with Nirvana!!!

Porcupine Tree In Absentia

9 mar 04

Voto:

Porcupine Tree are a phenomenal band for me, even though I don't know them very well. I will eventually buy this album, although I think I'll get Lightbulb Sun first... anyway, nice review... not very original... but well done...

Alicia Keys The Diary Of Alicia Keys

7 mar 04

Voto:

I should mention that I've been a fan of black music for not so long, but when I like something, I dive into it wholeheartedly. I would like to say that Alicia is talented, but I find myself puzzled when it comes to her compositions. I listened to "Song in A Minor" and it didn't impress me much... I definitely prefer the legendary Anastacia, who knows how to balance aggression and sweetness in a more harmonious way, and in my opinion, she has greater vocal ability (I've studied for 3 years at a modern music academy, so I'm not ignorant... just so you know...).
Anyway, well done, Kosmo... great review... expect my take on Thicke to come out soon... please make sure to read it when it does... because I consider you great, and your advice or judgments bring me immense pleasure.

Metallica St. Anger

5 mar 04

Voto:

How can you say "As is Trujillo's performance. He's settled in well. He knows his stuff when it comes to playing the bass." when he hasn't played a single note on the record??? Maybe you're referring to the live shows??
In my opinion, you tend to overlook some rather important details.. try to pay more attention next time... I'm not the only one here clearly making mistakes like you seemed to imply... right?
And then you practically said nothing about the type of music contained in St. Anger... I don’t know... eh, to think that I thought you were a great reviewer... okay, it's from a year ago, but how long have you been in? Recommend me one of your best reviews please because I'm curious to see the improvements...