TheSilentMan

DeRank ™: 0,05

DeAge™ : 8138 days • Here since 27 february 2004

Maudlin Of The Well Leaving Your Body Map

21 may 04

Voto:

I find that you have remarkable imagination and humor... too bad that they are overwhelmingly overshadowed by a flood of excessive words and a certain annoying egocentrism at times. Of course, the review is well written and at times entertaining... but it's long and tedious, leaving almost no imagination for the reader about what to expect when listening to the album... you've written better... more conciseness, fewer ramblings, and a bit less self-indulgence—even if it's just for fun—would make the review better...

Arcturus La Masquerade Infernale

21 may 04

Voto:

In the end, they're not all that much better, in my opinion, than the underrated Borknagar... as for the review, it's quite brief but well-written and has some brilliant insights. There’s still some thrashing to work on, but you’re on the right track!

Old Time Relijun Lost Light

21 may 04

Voto:

A review that really leaves too many points hanging... those who gave you three were too kind.. with a review like that, I would have received a 1, if not a 0.. here at de-b they're getting a bit soft, I think..
Anyway, you write well, I'll give you that.. and hopefully soon I'll give you a 5, or at least I really hope so..

Dream Theater Live At The Marquee

13 may 04

Voto:

I’ve never listened to the album, but you’ve piqued my curiosity. The review is very well done, congratulations, although you would have done well to talk a bit more about the genre proposed by the band since there are those who don’t know them, even though I know that often this is not considered. The rating of the review would be 4, but given how much you appreciate Moore and since I adore him and think that no one can be a worthy substitute for him in Dream Theater, I’m giving you a full 5. Well done… keep it up!

Iron Maiden Somewhere In Time

13 may 04

Voto:

The album isn’t bad, even though it’s certainly not one of Iron's best works... As for the review, I think you don’t write badly, but you somewhat overlooked the general aspects of a review.. you focused too much on praising this band, which truly deserves all your compliments, but keep in mind that there are those who don’t know them... Anyway.. good job anyway...

Megadeth Peace Sells...but Who's Buying?

27 apr 04

Voto:

In my opinion... rust in peace is unmatched by all the other Megadeth albums... anyway, this isn't too bad even though the sounds and Mustaine's singing are really off-putting...

Dream Theater When Dream And Day Unite

27 apr 04

Voto:

Certainly, DOminici wasn't a great singer... just listen to how the conversation changes in the parts he sang reinterpreted live by Labrie... as for the album, it was definitely interesting and innovative for its time... too bad about the recording quality and the sounds sometimes comparable to those of toy instruments...

Murderdolls Beyond The Valley Of Murderdolls

26 apr 04

Voto:

I don’t vote for either because I find both simply useless.. sorry Matteo but writing so little isn’t enough... and then the Murderdolls live only made me angry.. I mean the drummer had a kit almost like prog metal and he played it worse than I do... ugh and then all the songs sound similar... no, both you and the Murderdolls are a bust..

Bluvertigo Zero

20 apr 04

Voto:

Congratulations south really well done!

Deep Purple In Rock

18 apr 04

Voto:

So... first of all, this is certainly not the best Deep Purple album, but it is the most famous... it’s definitely a well-made album, but comparing it to albums like Burn or Stormbringer seems really excessive to me. What’s certain is that it’s an album that marked a turning point and showcased the true potential of a band that is often pitted against Led Zeppelin for some unknown reason, considering that a) the genre they propose is similar but significantly different, and b) technically Deep Purple are far above Led Zeppelin. As much as they say Jimmy Page is a good guitarist, I bet he couldn't pull off a Blackmore solo... in my opinion, he wouldn’t even manage it at half speed... Lastly, the review isn’t bad, but it’s too subjective and lacks some musical detail, in my opinion...