TheSilentMan

DeRank ™: 0,05

DeAge™ : 8138 days • Here since 27 february 2004

Nouvelle Vague Nouvelle Vague

1 oct 04

Voto:

Great review...very effective and inviting...but I really reserve a 5 only for the sublime...don't take it personally...;-P...congratulations! I think I will buy the album..

Damn, you could have talked a bit about Belladonna's performance too, he exists as well... singers are always underestimated!!! UGH, I PROTEST IN THE NAME OF THE LEAGUE OF SINGERS!!! Just kidding! Anyway, great album, nothing to say... the review isn’t bad, but I can't give you more than a 3.. ;-P

extrema live jestrai rock - bergamo

30 jun 04

Voto:

But should this be a report on a concert or a similar appearance of someone who got lost and by chance ended up listening to a band they don’t know a darn thing about, judging hypocritically a group of kids who could very well be their friends??? Down with hypocrisy... it's not at all a warm welcome from me... I’m sorry, but I hope you'll have the chance to redeem yourself...

Michael Jackson Dangerous

30 jun 04

Voto:

Mmmmm...I would say that personal emotions should be kept out of de-b, as many of you have mentioned regarding forums..or not, guys??? In fact, is writing a review with personal experiences perhaps worse??? To you...

Lenny Kravitz Baptism

30 jun 04

Voto:

The album isn't bad, even though Lenny talked about a very rock record, and to me, it doesn't seem that rock given all the pop pieces (nice, yes, but what a drag!). Anyway, the review isn't too bad; I think there are good ideas… now it just needs some work to develop them and give it a bit more personality… bienvenido!

Vasco Rossi Buoni O Cattivi

30 jun 04

Voto:

I think you focused too much on your own thought for its own sake... you should have considered being a bit more objective, as not everyone shares the same ideas. In my opinion, you definitely spoke little about the album itself, without mentioning how it compares to the previous stupid hotel (which I believe is definitely worse than this one), and without discussing other things that may be less profound but certainly more, let's say, "review-worthy"... if it weren't for this, as a writer I would give you a 5... but the review is worth a watered-down 3...

Slipknot Vol. 3 (The Subliminal Verses)

6 jun 04

Voto:

Thank you for confirming my theories about you.. congratulations... it's easy to offend and throw around random phrases, don't you think? Well, keep it up because as long as you're happy, everyone is happy.. (words like musical style, recording quality, packaging, booklet, and artwork are unknown to you, right?)

Shellac At Action Park

1 jun 04

Voto:

Sure, hummi, you could have put a little more emphasis on an album that, from what you told me, was magnificent... You disappointed me... you overlooked many details and, anyway, you didn't really describe much about this album... Despite everything, I'll give you a passing grade because you know how to write well...

Samuele Bersani Che vita! Il meglio di Samuele Bersani

23 may 04

Voto:

A well-made best of... that remains more of a commercial operation than anything else... As for the review, it's fairly well done, but it lacks even a brief description of some points such as, I don't know, the booklet, the actual music... the musicians... etc. Anyway, it's well written and enjoyable. Keep it up!!

Emperor In The Nightside Eclipse

21 may 04

Voto:

The album is a masterpiece, although a bit less chaotic sounds would have benefitted me... The review is well-written and very poetic. Too bad, in my opinion, that sometimes one needs to be a bit more mindful of the fact that it's still a review, and the task of a reviewer is nonetheless to provide an idea of what album they are reviewing without saying too much or too little... Anyway, good job, you can definitely reach high levels...