ossian1973

Fuck, Rhodes is a brand of keyboards, it’s called RANDY RHOADS, shit, the poor soul… Nick Rhodes is the keyboardist of Duran Duran, shit… it’s called RANDY not rhandi… anyway, the review is insane, trashy, you’re not an Ozzy fan, an Ozzy fan (but also anyone who has a minimal understanding of metal and rock in general) would never write such nonsense!!! Of course, I’m adding to the list of 'gnurant those who just commented giving you 3s and 4s without noticing the blasphemies being said...!!! You didn't talk about the music, and Van Halen is the MASTER of Randy Rhoads, who comes right after him… great Randy and great album.

Okay, ajeje, I shouldn’t be talking because I don’t know any of the groups mentioned, except for Pixies and Husker Du... but I was talking about Rock, not drum'n'bass, and the revival itself, in the name of the genre, speaks volumes about originality. I didn't say that today's groups are the same as those from yesterday, and I agree that Rock continuously changes; the fact is that I don’t see historically important groups, even if I’ve never heard of them (sorry for the impertinence). I don’t believe that in 40 years Tortoise or Slint will be remembered like Pink Floyd or Black Sabbath are today... maybe it’s a matter of taste, but the history of rock is something different. I hope I’ve been clear; I didn’t say that there aren’t great bands today that are enjoyable to listen to.

Rock is doing great; I absolutely won’t comment on tastes. I’m sorry we think differently about originality. As for Nirvana, I can say that musically there may have been something similar before, you’re right, even in the same Seattle. I meant that they were original also in terms of video, look, and attitudes; even today, many bands are more or less their clones. P.S. Can I know what rock genres were invented in the 2000s and a few names of original bands? Maybe I’m a bit behind, thanks!!

Ah, about the singers of is Corprei, there's a good thing to say: the wife!!!

Antonino, my rating is only a 3 because some songs are a 2, others a 5; overall, I find the album less interesting than "The Piper," "Meddle," "Atom Heart Mother," "The Wall," and "Dark Side of the Moon," which I rate 5. Naturally, this is just my personal opinion; I’m not saying that historically "A Saucerful.." is worth less. For example, I would give "Animals" and "Wish You Were Here" a 2, even though I admit I don't know "Animals" very well—I’ve tried to appreciate it, but maybe I need to insist! Antimo, I wanted to say that eventually all the veins run dry; I can understand that there are quality bands, but originality really no... mixing previous genres or making them a bit more modern doesn’t mean being original, and I think this applies to contemporary art, too. In a way, it’s true that rock will never die, at least as an attitude, but when I hear that bands like Coldplay are original, it gives me chills. What were Pink Floyd then?? Look at today’s style; they all seem like freaks, but I’m also tired of it. Woodstock was a long time ago...

"master of puppets" and "Reign in Blood".... do you hear (in my opinion) how they are very, very different: vocals (timbre and singing style), rhythm guitars (Metallica never use death metal rhythms on an open string without muting), lead guitars (Slayer are unique, more classic Hammett), drums (does Dave Lombardo have anything to do with Lars Ulrich?), and finally the lyrics; let's also consider the look, which at the time was drastically different (black leather and spikes for Slayer, Vans, ripped jeans, and Misfits-style t-shirts for Metallica, along with Cliff’s legendary bell-bottom jeans). It seems to me that I’m stating things that can’t be contested, am I wrong? MZ414ZM, feel free to be stunned if I start cursing at you; you’d blush, but I won’t do it because I’m in public, so don’t use bad words, naughty child (of mind, and not of age; being young is not a negative thing!!!)!! Earl, in my opinion, Kreator make thrash-death, maybe with some black metal nuances occasionally, but to define them only as death or thrash might be reductive, I think. Can I ask you two questions? 1) What do you think about the differences between "Master.." and "Reign..." that I mentioned above? 2) How would you define "Reign in Blood" with Barney from Napalm on vocals?

Earl was not referring to you but to newbies who take the "old ones" as mere decorations and believe they are super informed about genres and everything else, but they have no roots and/or perhaps they don’t even know them. As for genres and subgenres, what you say is true, but be honest, it’s also true that the discussion developed because I said that Slayer (and Reign in Blood first...) are Death metal; I wasn’t answered that it’s not a matter of genres, but I sparked a storm to which you also adhered! I don’t want to be respected for the sake of it, but damn, I’ve been listening to metal and its relatives for 20 years now, and I repeat, I know truly extreme music, I love the noisecore of Patareni, and I consider Napalm Death quite catchy… since I’ve happened to hear 15-20-year-olds who have told me "oh how powerful Pantera are and how original," I put my hands up; originals are Voivod, certainly not Pantera.

Ah, I didn't know it was vekkia, you had told those who liked Pink post - Meddle to go listen to "the division bell"!!!

Ah the grade, good luck Antonino, guys don’t be too critical! The grade 3 is "sufficient" or am I wrong?

Hey Caz, but fucking hell, no... if you compare any album post "Meddle" to "The Division Bell," we're out of our minds (even though I’ve never actually listened to it)... go ahead and say that "The Wall" and "The Dark Side..." don’t appeal to you or are different from the early Pink Floyd, but when you compare them to the works of the pigs post-Waters, no... come on... seriously... p.s. Siouxsie & the Banshees, Joy Division, U2, Cure, Nick Cave, Black Flag, Descendents, Misfits, etc. etc. etc. aren’t they '80s bands? and what are they, crap? well, life is strange, rock for me died in the very early '90s, the only ones who brought significant innovation and are still imitated today are Nirvana... the '80s were just as FLORID as the previous decades.