Woody Allen Match Point
Woody Allen Match Point
3 jun 07
Voto:
I liked it; I have a soft spot for Scarlett, but the film undoubtedly works, especially due to the actors. Not a masterpiece, but certainly noteworthy.
Darren Lynn Bousman Saw 3
Darren Lynn Bousman Saw 3
3 jun 07
Voto:
Halloween is so outdated that even Scream can look down on it...
The Chemical Brothers Dig Your Own Hole
The Chemical Brothers Dig Your Own Hole
3 jun 07
Voto:
discone
Terrence Malick The New World
Terrence Malick The New World
3 jun 07
Voto:
if it hadn't been a Malick film, it would have gone completely unnoticed
Sam Raimi Darkman
Sam Raimi Darkman
3 jun 07
Voto:
I saw it centuries ago, I remember it as disarmingly mediocre... not bad in the strict sense, you know, but lacking in every area... it was unfortunate enough to be released shortly after Burton's Batman, and there's simply no comparison.
Lloyd Kaufman, Michael Herz The Toxic Avenger
Lloyd Kaufman, Michael Herz The Toxic Avenger
3 jun 07
Voto:
If you really like the genre, this and chapter 4 are among the best. What would you consider the milestones of the genre? That this "cannot be judged as a true film" is a nonsensical phrase; rather, reiterate that you think it's crap et bon. Since the product in question is a manifesto of the genre, you’ll have to do better to convince us that you are criticizing the film and not the genre. As I said before, I could also say that The Producers is unwatchable crap, but if in the end it turns out that I actually hate musicals, how much is my judgment on the product worth?
Lloyd Kaufman, Michael Herz The Toxic Avenger
Lloyd Kaufman, Michael Herz The Toxic Avenger
3 jun 07
Voto:
Maybe you didn’t quite get the point: this stuff is clearly trash. So if you don’t like the genre at all, what’s the point of reviewing it? It’s like reading a review of a musical by someone who hates the genre.
Darren Lynn Bousman Saw 3
Darren Lynn Bousman Saw 3
2 jun 07
Voto:
ah, of course neorealist films like Cannibal Holocaust are of a completely different genre, so don't even think about mentioning them.
Darren Lynn Bousman Saw 3
Darren Lynn Bousman Saw 3
2 jun 07
Voto:
Giving a 5 to this movie is an insult? Alright, find me a better slasher than this.
Darren Lynn Bousman Saw 3
Darren Lynn Bousman Saw 3
2 jun 07
Voto:
you're a fool... They haven't even started shooting Saw 4! From your description, I'd say like the others you reviewed the third one... and even there you messed it up... unlike the excellent first one and the terrible second, here the weak point is precisely the plot, which is really just a flimsy excuse to pour buckets of blood in the viewer's face. In terms of classic horror/thriller, Saw 3 is a failure; in terms of pure slasher, it's a masterpiece.
Similar users
Rewards
january 2010
week 4 - 2010