ma proprio proprio

DeRank ™: 0,00

DeAge™ : 7657 days • Here since 24 june 2005

Metallica Master Of Puppets

19 dec 05

Voto:

Excuse me, amused: so you agree in saying that the ruling class on the right (just like for you, the one on the left) is profoundly ignorant except for a few thinkers?

Sorry Noel, but what does it have to do with anything? Here, no one is a musician and no one says they are better than them... however, compared to other bands, they are quite mediocre. The fact that they have sold so much says very little about their artistic quality...

Jimi Hendrix Warner Bros DVD

29 nov 05

Voto:

hahahahaha

Oasis Don't Believe The Truth

17 nov 05

Voto:

Come on, you can't get mad... Anyway, I gave you a 1 because it's lacking, it's not objective at all and it doesn't explain the various songs thoroughly. I would have given a bit more, but I repeat, you can't define The Importance that way: essentially, you give a zero rating to The Importance, but you don't even explain why (except for the reference to the voice), you don't say how the song is structured, etc.

Oasis Don't Believe The Truth

16 nov 05

Voto:

votes

Oasis Don't Believe The Truth

16 nov 05

Voto:

But: I believe that the review is really very well written. I don't like the album that much and obviously, from the standpoint of my ignorance, I find your positive judgments exaggerated. However, I absolutely think it's idiotic that anyone who hears the word Oasis allows themselves to insult and ramble. I don’t quite understand why you exalt yourself to such an extent; it makes me think that perhaps there’s a good reason, for example that you’re really good, but usually those who are truly good don’t self-aggrandize to that degree, even though self-exaltation doesn’t exclude the possibility of being genuinely skilled. Time will tell; who knows, in 30 years you might be famous for being a great journalist and music critic... for now, I can only say that I find your unabashed praise for such a band quite astonishing.

Oasis Don't Believe The Truth

16 nov 05

Voto:

Look, I'm not crazy about Oasis, actually. However, The Importance of Being Idle is very beautiful; I don't understand why you say it even sucks. The rest of the album is mediocre, indeed. I'm sorry, but the review deserves a 1.

Dream Theater Images and Words

11 nov 05

Voto:

As someone mentioned above, if you truly want to laugh, read Queen II by critic music...a masterpiece..
Nice album, but I had heard such good things that I thought it would be better...in the end, they're a metal band.. I don’t know, I expected them to be more engaging..3.7

U2 How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb

25 oct 05

Voto:

Yeah... the greatest rock band of all time...

Queen + Paul Rodgers Return Of The Champions

10 oct 05

Voto:

I went to the concert in Milan and I have to say it was a great emotion, even though Rodgers didn't sing well at all. However, I will never buy the record; it seems really embarrassing to me. I give it a 1 for encouragement. The review is painful... just like that of Queen II... are you the same??