hobbit

stunning... true. and warm, highly emotional... the only thing you didn’t mention is the interpretation of "exit", even darker than on the record... for the rest, nothing to add... be careful because at certain moments it can make you cry ("bad" above all)

put us the year... it's 1969

brilliant

ok

not exactly the best of Pink Floyd musically... (Dogs and Pigs (Three Different Ones) don’t excite me, but Pigs on the Wing and Sheep do). However, the lyrics are exceptional... I feel the same way about The Wall...

"You might like it"... aaargh

Why doesn’t anyone vote? The review is good, it explains the album's features well, but I don’t agree with what you say... reckoning is not essential, first of all; then it’s logical that you might like it, but it’s still a transitional album. In my opinion, the truly beautiful ones here are harborcoat, letter never sent, central rain, and rockville; camera and pretty persuasion are a step below... as for time after time, I much prefer the acoustic version that's included as a bonus on the remastered document; instead of seven chinese brothers, listen to (if you haven’t already) the b-side "voice of harold," it’s the same song with different lyrics and played in a rougher, more "rock" way... I believe it’s on dead letter office (I’m not sure, I downloaded it...). PS: the score is just below 4, but since it’s R.E.M...

X odradek: well, it's not that it's such a famous story, so I thought your name might mean something else (although I was wondering if there might be another thing associated with "odradek"). In fact, I went to your profile to see if the reference was correct, but there was nothing written. Then when you talked about the spool of thread, you gave me certainty... long live Kafka, my favorite author (among the not many that I know).

So the name "Odradek" is indeed taken from Kafka's story?

three reviews of the blue? really? are we joking? okay, I know we’re on "DEBASER reviews written by anyone," but, for goodness' sake, as if it needs to be said that the blue are terrible... on debaser we talk about music, and the blue don't belong in that category, so PLEASE STOP WITH THE REVIEWS ON THE BLUE...