manliuzzo

DeRank ™: 2,48

DeAge™ : 6987 days • Here since 24 april 2007

Eminem Stan

26 jun 07

Voto:

Yes, I indeed love progressive, but my first passion (albeit minimal) was rap. I think I am objective because I appreciated rap, but I have never loved it as much as progressive. Therefore, if I judge a progressive album, I might not be objective and I’ll let myself go with the ratings, but if I judge a rap album, which I've never considered my favorite musical genre, I will be very objective. That’s why I say that Fabri Fibra can't even put together a decent rhyme, but I acknowledge the talent of Frankie Hi nrg and the skill of Eminem, who you can say anything about, but he knows how to deliver rhymes. Nowadays, rap isn't much. Mondo Marcio, for example, whom I consider a notch above Fabri Fibra, doesn’t do it for me. But rap isn’t all trash, believe me...

Genesis Foxtrot

26 jun 07

Voto:

Riccardo, I didn't mean to say idiot, but incompetent. Because you can't take a review of an artist or an album and give it a rating that deviates from the reviewer's judgment. So there are two options: either you start doing the reviews yourself or you can ignore this fucking site that isn't really useful anyway.

Genesis Foxtrot

26 jun 07

Voto:

What has baffled me are the scores. The review of the artist is from Ondarock, so the judgments expressed in words correspond to the scores from Ondarock, not those from Scaruffi.

Genesis Foxtrot

26 jun 07

Voto:

Yes, but Ondarock gives more acceptable scores.

Genesis Foxtrot

26 jun 07

Voto:

Well, maybe I saw it wrong. The King Crimson grace it greatly though.

Genesis Foxtrot

26 jun 07

Voto:

I don’t think I understood correctly: does Ondarock copy from Scaruffi?

Genesis Foxtrot

26 jun 07

Voto:

Riccardo, are you Scaruffi? I mean: a 6 for Banco del Mutuo Soccorso is outrageous, a 6.5 for Io sono nato libero is disgusting, a 7 for Darwin is already acceptable. But a 6.5 for Storia di un Minuto and Aria, no, noooo. He was generous with Genesis and King Crimson. Then he gave a 4 to Come in un'ultima cena; it may not be a great album, but a 4? The best ratings, in my opinion, are those from OndaRock, balanced and impartial. That’s a great site, and Scaruffi just copies those reviews. Idiot.

Genesis Foxtrot

26 jun 07

Voto:

Scaruffi's ratings for Banco: Banco del mutuo soccorso (1972), 6/10
Darwin (1972), 7/10
Io sono nato libero (1973), 6.5/10
Garofano rosso (1976), 3/10
Come in un'ultima cena (1976), 4/10
Di Terra (1977), 5/10
Canto di Primavera (1979), 5/10
Capolinea (1979), live
Urgentissimo (1980), 3/10
Buone notizie (1981), 3/10
...e via (1985), 3/10
Da qui messere si domina la valle (1991), 4/10
il 13 (1994), 3/10
Nudo (1997), 6.5/10.
What do you say, should I hit him?

Genesis Foxtrot

26 jun 07

Voto:

Votes for Pfm: Storia di un Minuto (Numero Uno, 1972), 6.5/10
Per Un Amico (1972), 6/10
L'Isola di Niente (1974), 6/10
Chocolate Kings (Asylum, 1975), 5/10
Jet Lag (1977), 5/10
Should I kill him?

Genesis Foxtrot

26 jun 07

Voto:

Votes for Pfm: Storia di un Minuto (Numero Uno, 1972), 6.5/10
Per Un Amico (1972), 6/10
L'Isola di Niente (1974), 6/10
Chocolate Kings (Asylum, 1975), 5/10
Jet Lag (1977), 5/10
Should I kill him?