ArnoldLayne

DeRank ™: 7,10

DeAge™ : 6991 days • Here since 20 april 2007

Love Contact

Avril Lavigne The Best Damn Thing

27 apr 07

Voto:

Undisputed masterpiece. It's rare to find a record worse than this, so congratulations!!

Pink Floyd The Piper at the gates of dawn

27 apr 07

Voto:

Isis, I feel sorry for you.

Pink Floyd The Piper at the gates of dawn

27 apr 07

Voto:

Bubi, you’re mistaken.. Barrett is featured in 3-4 songs.

Beatles Sgt.Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band

27 apr 07

Voto:

But what the hell does the American garage have to do with it?

Pink Floyd The Dark Side of the Moon

27 apr 07

Voto:

And then excuse me, but what does Careful's scream have to do with this album? Nothing, it seems to me.

Dream Theater A Change Of Seasons

27 apr 07

Voto:

Too much enthusiasm for a listenable suite and masterfully executed covers, if it weren't for LaBrie. The score is just for the suite.

The Beatles Sergeant Pepper Lonely Hearts Club Band

27 apr 07

Voto:

Ahah! Very scruffy in this review! What stands out in the middle is the phrase copied word for word, but that’s okay! It’s certainly not the best rock album, nor one of the best, and I too tend to downplay it in hindsight, but listening to it doesn’t bother me at all. I agree with many things you say, but, I repeat, the only shortcomings of this album are the cleverness and the fact that it has been overrated, but I like it.

Pink Floyd The Dark Side of the Moon

27 apr 07

Voto:

Well, I don't care about the background nor does it affect me personally. I evaluate this album without looking at the previous ones, and no matter what they say, it will never lose an ounce of its original value. I understand you want to say these things, but when I listen to The Dark Side of the Moon, it's always the heart that prevails, I'm sorry.

Pink Floyd The Piper at the gates of dawn

27 apr 07

Voto:

Oh, I almost forgot: the album is the best in history.

Pink Floyd The Piper at the gates of dawn

27 apr 07

Voto:

Well, in my opinion, the final considerations could have been avoided, especially the reference to Waters' little birds and the unworthy adjective you use for Shine on... but for the rest, impeccable review. It's likely that on A Saucerful of Secrets, Syd collaborated or simply played on 3 or 4 tracks.