GrantNicholas

Great band, I still need to hear this. To me, even though I'm not a fan of the genre, I have liked all their previous works.

@MIKE 76: I reviewed Groff, go read it... he he...

Perfect review, as you always do. I'm jealous, you write too well.

Hello captain. 5 of standard for you.

It's clear that innovation is fundamental in music; there's no doubt about it. However, the Gallaghers are not innovators, and this has been known for a long time. So, those seeking innovation should look elsewhere.

Dear Neu!, I don't know if you’re addressing me, but anyway: I’ve listened to at least three-quarters of the albums you mentioned, but the point I often argue on Debaser is different: I notice that many people evaluate songs and albums based on the degree of INNOVATION. I, however, believe that INNOVATION does not necessarily equal QUALITY. There can be albums that attempt innovative paths but end up being terrible, or hyper-derivative albums that come out as masterpieces. For me, Morning Glory belongs to the second category. Wonderwall and DLBIA are not innovative, but they are incredibly beautiful. Oh, and one more thing: don’t dare say that I rate things based on my preferences, because that’s a colossal lie. Anyone who reads my reviews or comments knows that at least impartiality is a trait I’ve always possessed. For example, I would kiss Michael Stipe’s feet (ugh! let’s not exaggerate), but in my review of Monster, I gave it two stars and stirred up a storm, so...

For me, and I know I will spark hatred for this, it remains an absolute masterpiece and one of the most beautiful and emotional albums of the last fifteen years. "Wonderwall," "Don't Look Back In Anger," and "Champagne Supernova" have become classics that will endure through the years. They are not innovative geniuses; they do not (despite their famous bravado) claim to be considered artists (Noel has repeatedly stated that only Radiohead and Coldplay deserve such a label in the English scene). Those who hate them usually do so out of pure personal dislike (which is understandable; they are certainly not the epitome of likability, even though I met Liam at Bebop in Florence and he is anything but unfriendly). They are considered excessively derivative (and that is true), but the question is: how many excessively derivative bands have come out in recent years? Many. And how many have written a "Wonderwall"? None, or almost none. It's clear that those who hate them will continue to hate them, but the beauty of life is that everyone has their own opinion. For me, they have earned a little corner in the history of rock. The album that, at the age of 11, changed my life (musically).

Okay. Everything’s clear!

@ Greenmachine: I don’t know Nada Surf well enough to give you a fully comprehensive answer, but I have noticed some analogies, now that you mention it. The only side project from Death Cab I know of is that fantastic project called Postal Service. Highly recommended.

Hi Ale. Life is going pretty well, my company has moved and I have a lot on my plate, but we're getting settled and now I have more time to come to Debaser. Hey, I'm a bit short on listens lately. Recommend something to me, if you feel like it.