alessioIRIDE

DeRank ™: 3,14

DeAge™ : 7071 days • Here since 31 january 2007

Melvins A Live History Of Gluttony And Lust

11 may 07

Voto:

you’re just missing a few million neurons and a few thousand indie and hardcore records! anyway, LONG LIVE SLURP MERDAL and anyone who creates those fucking definitions like the ones you spit out with every breath. by the way, I’ve decided that the genre made by the melvins is called CAZZOMOSCIO and it derives from Gregorian chants sung by ravenous wolves. so now they don’t do SLURP or BOOM anymore, but CAZZOMOSCIO! bye

Melvins A Live History Of Gluttony And Lust

11 may 07

Voto:

Melvins A Live History Of Gluttony And Lust

11 may 07

Voto:

So starting from the assumption that the Melvins vary millions of times within a single album (let alone from one album to another), how can you categorize them as metal? In my opinion, it's impossible... they create a genre that only they do, and it's a genre that I would call Melvins. Period. Anyway, come on, you can't deny that, at least ideologically, the Melvins stem from My War, the Flipper, Black Flag? I mean, they don't have a limited interest in just one thing... just look at the covers they do... I mean, what the hell does "Youth of America" by the Wipers have to do with "Going Blind" by Kiss?

Dinosaur Jr. Dinosaur Jr.

11 may 07

Voto:

you're almost cool...but there's still something missing!!!

Melvins A Live History Of Gluttony And Lust

11 may 07

Voto:

What the hell are you talking about? I didn't say anything! Not that they do punk, nor that they do slurp metal! I said that the Melvins do the Melvins (that said, that's all said). Don't jump to stupid conclusions, and anyway, it seems undeniable to me that the type of music they make was born from the B-side of My War... but if you say otherwise... let's just go with the no... no worries. Do one thing: get out of the hole where you live, take a stroll around the shops, and tell me if there's Houdini! Okay?

Dinosaur Jr. Dinosaur Jr.

11 may 07

Voto:

but how is my war not slurp metal? slip it in isn't boom metal? peggiopunx you’re losing your touch...what the hell...come on, learn a couple of new definitions and then come here to show off...we're waiting for you!!!

Melvins A Live History Of Gluttony And Lust

11 may 07

Voto:

Well, if you say there is... there is. Thank God! I bow before you. In any case, yours are just your opinions and not the realities... when you are God, everything will be as you want it, but for now I keep my own... which, for me, doesn't make slurp metal... if it does for you... who the fuck cares... also, having said what you said about Cobain... you've said it all! Bye bye!

Dinosaur Jr. Dinosaur Jr.

11 may 07

Voto:

In my opinion, you're not talking about just any group, but the Melvins. I mean, the Melvins make music that's too elaborate to be considered metal... it's too reductive to label them as just metal. In any case, Slip It In is metal too, right? My War is the same!

Melvins A Live History Of Gluttony And Lust

11 may 07

Voto:

ghermison lives in Bologna and even there he can't be found...strange case of life, don't you think? I never said that the Melvins copy Black Flag or do hardcore...what's for sure is that they don't do metal...not at all. Anyway, I think you've been listening to this little band for a while now...maybe 1 or 2 years? It seems you still need to digest them enough...wait a little longer before drawing conclusions...

Dinosaur Jr. Dinosaur Jr.

11 may 07

Voto:

I know something, but not well. Anyway, I wasn't referring to "mista," but to the idiot who goes by the name of puntinicazpuntini. He’s convinced that the Melvins are metal... but can you imagine a metal band opening for Dinosaur Jr and playing before Nirvana? Anyway, leaving those things aside... the Melvins don't make crap.