c'è Banned

DeRank ™: 12,64

DeAge™ : 7211 days • Here since 14 september 2006

Led Zeppelin Remasters

21 jun 07

Voto:

@Zanna: I meant those who are influential for my personal way of playing, not in general. I was saying that in the end, influence is a personal thing. @Black Dog, Led Zeppelin took their sound from Cream, the same goes for Black Sabbath. @Cornell, no one told you to fuck off; I just said that objectively the review is terrible. You're the one who took it further; you know what I care about? I don’t care about a greatest hits of Led Zeppelin, I prefer the originals.

Patti Smith Twelve

21 jun 07

Voto:

How can you give this a 3? I thought you'd be harsher; it doesn't deserve a passing grade. All covers, with the added offense of having chosen all top-tier tracks, and the even graver issue of having made one worse than the other.

Led Zeppelin Remasters

20 jun 07

Voto:

You’re really good with verbs, too bad there are sentences in your review like this: "Some claim, and in my opinion, this opinion is completely wrong, that they have been greatly overrated. To these gentlemen, I can say: if you were Led Zeppelin, you’d be quite upset with such a statement… Considering the hard work these four have put in, to call them overrated is a downright heresy." At least have the humility to admit that you wrote a terrible review instead of the arrogance in your comment. Bye.

Led Zeppelin Remasters

20 jun 07

Voto:

the most influential of all time? Robert Johnson and Chuck Berry

Led Zeppelin Remasters

20 jun 07

Voto:

Then, in fact, on a personal level, the most influential guitarists on my way of playing have been Clapton first and foremost, Page and Iommi in equal measure, with a sprinkle of Keith Richards and Neil Young here and there, so influence is a subjective matter. The votes.

Led Zeppelin Remasters

20 jun 07

Voto:

I hope the reviewer won’t take it personally, but the review is really terrible, one of the worst I’ve read. I don't think there are more influential groups overall: I see Sabbath, Cream, Stones, and Yardbirds a bit above. In the comments, it seems I read someone trying to categorize Led Zeppelin as progressive; I don’t believe that, this is hard rock, or hard blues. To tell the truth, I don't even know what this record is.