"The Departed" is not "The Goodfellas" nor "Casino," and it’s not even remotely comparable to two of the peaks of Scorsese's cinema. Here, Scorsese's focus is on the audience and the box office more than on realism and plausibility as in the masterpieces of 1990 and 1995. Setting this aspect aside, however, the film is formally very good, the director's mastery is evident, Di Caprio is good, Nicholson is excellent, Sheen is solid, but it's too bad about the mediocre Damon, yet ultimately the film is very beautiful.
more