Cover of Arctic Monkeys Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not
AnaK

• Rating:

For fans of arctic monkeys, indie rock lovers, punk rock enthusiasts, music collectors, new listeners exploring british indie bands
 Share

THE REVIEW

Debut album of the Sheffield band, England, from 2006, received recognition from both Rolling Stone (and I don't know if that's much of a compliment) and NME. The four English lads, who had already impressed enthusiasts with some singles released before the album, do not disappoint.

"The View From The Afternoon" opens the album and immediately introduces us to a fast rhythm, not very indie, almost more punk-rock, but Alex's voice takes us back to the indie world. Not bad as an opening track! I recommend searching for the video of this song on YouTube, live at the Apollo, with extraordinary multi-camera shots of Matt Helders, the Arctic drummer. Something that can seriously make you faint!

In second place, we find the beautiful "I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor", with an incessant rhythm at the start, a nice drum part (Agile Beast = Matt Helders NEVER disappoints), and an initial guitar solo by Alex. Then the rhythm slows down in the verse but picks up speed in the chorus. Engaging. Definitely "dancefloor" material.

Third track: "Fake Tales of San Francisco" - perhaps one of the most well-known Arctic songs, even to those not in the know. Of simple execution (I think it's one of the most covered songs nowadays, a sort of modern "Blitzkrieg Pop"), sometimes a bit bland (see the second verse with that incessant guitar passage from the 5th to 7th fret that seems like a litany) but catchy and with a nice bass line.

"Dancing Shoes" holds back at first with good palm-muting and an almost tribal rhythm, then unleashes in the second verse and opens completely to the audience. I would like to point out the difference in execution of this and many other songs (even from other albums) from the official album to the demo. Interesting.

"You Probably Couldn't See For The Lights But You Were Staring Straight At Me" in fifth place, with its lengthy title, still offers a nice rhythm and a truly interesting voice from Alex, but certainly not the best track on the album.

However, "Still Take You Home" is wonderful, with another frenetic start but not faltering even in the verse. It wanes a bit after the brief solo (the woo ooh oooh part for clarification), but let's give Alex a breather! The album version is very nice, but the live version from the "Live at the Apollo - Manchester" concert deserves a mention: a sing-along moment. "Oh you don't know nothing no!"

"Riot Van" is a song I would definitely call indie. I don't know why, but it's the feeling I get when I hear it. A decidedly calm start, without drums, with this quite effected voice, a bit offbeat, then the bass drum and hi-hat timidly make their way in, but always in the background, as Turner's voice is the absolute master. Slow, an indie ballad.

Follows "Red Light Indicates Doors Are Secured", modest, with this bass line that repeats continuously, almost trance-like, until the chorus and then returns the same. Good on first listen, a bit boring after 4 years of listening!

Credit to "Mardy Bum", a song I particularly love, it starts with a brief solo by Alex. Who knows how many girls have identified with Mardy...!

"Perhaps Vampires Is A Bit Strong But.." isn't bad, a bit of effects for both guitar and voice, it has an almost syncopated rhythm (Helders is divine, but there's no need to keep saying it!) XD

Then comes "When the Sun Goes Down". It surprises us as it starts quietly, with this "scummy man", without drums, and nice chord transitions and climbing up the neck at the end, then it breaks into an extraordinary rhythm we never would have expected at the start (but we're talking Arctic Monkeys here, we can't start with preconceptions!). Scream the chorus! Then it closes as it began, quiet again.

"From the Ritz to the Rubble", second to last track, starts out almost unfriendly, again just guitar and voice, then the group's rhythm part comes in, and the song begins to take shape. At first it seemed almost senseless, but at the chorus you understand that it all makes sense! "Too deep but how deep is too deep" is particularly beautiful. And I particularly like the second verse (note that the backing vocals are often Matt's, this awesome drummer).

The album closes (and what a closure!) with the 5.31 minutes of "A Certain Romance", introduced by a fantastic drum rhythm to which the guitar then joins, only after the first minute does the bass and finally at minute 1.19 does the voice make its appearance. We are immersed in a calm rhythm (almost reggae if you will) where Alex's voice and the guitar part blend perfectly. The solo part is great, where some previously suppressed power explodes. A song I personally adore.

So we've finished listening to and analyzing the first album of the 4 English indie artists, to be listened to again, savored and, why not, played!

Loading comments  slowly

Summary by Bot

This review praises Arctic Monkeys’ 2006 debut album for its infectious energy, blending indie and punk rock elements effectively. Key tracks like 'I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor' and 'A Certain Romance' are highlighted. The reviewer also values live performances and unique execution differences between album and demos. Overall, it's a compelling and recommendable listen for indie fans.

Tracklist Lyrics Videos

01   The View From the Afternoon (03:38)

Read lyrics

02   I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor (02:53)

Read lyrics

03   Fake Tales of San Francisco (02:58)

Read lyrics

04   Dancing Shoes (02:21)

Read lyrics

05   You Probably Couldn't See for the Lights but You Were Staring Straight at Me (02:10)

Read lyrics

06   Still Take You Home (02:53)

Read lyrics

08   Red Light Indicates Doors Are Secured (02:23)

10   Perhaps Vampires Is a Bit Strong But... (04:28)

Read lyrics

11   When the Sun Goes Down (03:20)

Read lyrics

12   From the Ritz to the Rubble (03:13)

Read lyrics

13   A Certain Romance (05:31)

Read lyrics

Arctic Monkeys

Arctic Monkeys are an English rock band formed in Sheffield (2002). They rose to prominence with their 2006 debut Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not and have released several stylistically varied albums including Favourite Worst Nightmare, Humbug, Suck It and See, AM, Tranquility Base Hotel & Casino and The Car.
28 Reviews

Other reviews

By regular_isa

 These guys are not like all the others you’ve listened to while remaining 'almost' impassive.

 Great drums, an insistent bass line, skewed and non-skewed guitars, and raspy voices chase each other in a work that is simple and fun but, at the same time, as surprising as a rock album should be.


By Donjunio1

 Three-quarters of this record is crap.

 Rock and roll is really something else.


By Sickboy

 The dazzling sparkle of 'I Bet You Look Good On The Dancefloor' woke me from my THC dreams.

 I hope the Monkeys saga isn’t a one-off and that we proceed to a slow (but not too slow) screwing of the record companies.


By Jack Darko

 "A great debut album that paves the way for a great career."

 "It’s a homogeneous album that follows a certain order but manages to always be innovative in mixing instrumental roles and sometimes reversing them."


By tetsuoironman

 What the hell is this damned mix of guitars played shoddily with a voice that makes Britney Spears shudder?

 Did I say rock ‘n’ roll is dead? I meant to say: music is dead.


There are 7 reviews of Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not on DeBaser.
You can find all the details on the work page.