Cover of The Strokes First Impressions of Earth
whereismymind

• Rating:

For fans of the strokes,indie rock lovers,rock music critics,julian casablancas followers,listeners interested in album reviews
 Share

THE REVIEW

I hope it's known to everyone that the Matrix trilogy doesn't exist because after the first masterpiece, the second and third films are respectively a non-film (besides, Bellucci acts in it and it's not a porn, so I don't know what she's doing there) and the negation of a film that compared to "Vacanze Sul Nilo" delves deeper into the characters.

Well, "First Impressions Of Earth" is Matrix 2.

After 2 albums, of which one was fantastic (especially in times of scarcity) and another one not to be dismissed, the Strokes cunningly decide it's already time to slack off and start believing their own hype without remembering that even Genesis wrote a great album ("Selling England By The Pound") and another one not to be dismissed ("The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway") only to turn into one of the most annoying and musically stale things you can find attached to instruments.

Julian "the best of the Coliseum" Casablancas really wants to create an image for his group as our version of the Rolling Stones, all sex and nihilism, forgetting that compared to the pre-80s Stones (but why didn't you stop! you could've stayed at home listening to "Wild Horses" on loop or counting how many normal mouths fit into one of Jagger's), they have a frontman who isn't worth even a lip of Mick and, above all, they lack a lot of talent and originality (besides not having a guitarist who, at 70, still dives headfirst off palm trees), so amidst changes of producers and unearned status to uphold comes out a harmless album, useless, actually just bad, but really bad.

"You Only Live Once" "Heart In A Cage" "On The Other Side" "Ask Me Anything" "Electricityscape" "Killing Lies" "Fear Of Sleep" "Ize Of The World" "Evening Sun" "Red Light" are the typical useless songs that even listening to them for a whole month won't stick with you, you can't even say they're bad because they're just background, you play them while you watch for the hundredth time Djorkaeff's overhead kick against Roma and they're there making noise.

Dishonorable mention for the extremely annoying "Razorblade" and "15 Minutes" in which Casablancas sounds drunk.

The only ones that stand out are "Juicebox", driven by splendid guitar and bass but which if they'd called it "Brand New Cadillac by The Clash Redone by Us" would've been quicker, and the surprising "Vision Of Division" that doesn't seem like theirs but is engaging and memorable.

Besides this, there's a great basic technique (with the singer in a half-asleep state, who has gone from having a unique and captivating voice in the first two albums to a droning lullaby not even like Bonomelli's) especially in the riffs, and a much better production than before which, in my opinion, took even more away from the album making it antiseptic and very distant from the raw simplicity of the beginnings.

Who might like it: the deaf, the parents and relatives of Casablancas, Valensi, Moretti, Fraiture, and Hammond, anyone who has just listened to something worse.

I don't give it a 1 for the few positive reasons listed earlier and because if I give this album a 1, what score do I give to Justin(e) Timberlake?

 

Loading comments  slowly

Summary by Bot

The review compares 'First Impressions of Earth' to the weaker sequels of the Matrix films, criticizing The Strokes for losing their originality and declining in quality. While the production is cleaner and there are a few standout tracks like 'Juicebox' and 'Vision Of Division,' most songs are forgettable background noise. Julian Casablancas' vocals are described as dull compared to earlier albums. Ultimately, the album is seen as a disappointment for fans expecting more.

Tracklist Lyrics Videos

01   You Only Live Once (03:09)

Read lyrics

03   Heart in a Cage (03:27)

Read lyrics

05   On the Other Side (04:38)

Read lyrics

06   Vision of Division (04:20)

Read lyrics

07   Ask Me Anything (03:12)

Read lyrics

08   Electricityscape (03:33)

Read lyrics

09   Killing Lies (03:50)

Read lyrics

10   Fear of Sleep (04:00)

Read lyrics

12   Ize of the World (04:29)

Read lyrics

The Strokes

The Strokes are an American rock band from New York City, formed in 1998, widely associated with the early-2000s garage rock/post-punk revival and breakthrough success with their debut album “Is This It”.
26 Reviews

Other reviews

By Alberto Giordano

 "You Only Live Once" is truly a beautiful song, fully in the Strokes' style.

 The 4 is for the passion I have for this band whose brazenness is exhibited in such a way that it can’t be considered anything but elegant.


By JULIANHAMPSHIRE

 After the first listens, quite disappointed.

 Julian’s voice, which had impressed me so much, is at times incredibly dull and highlights its limits.


By Adil

 "You Only Live Once" is the best calling card they could rely on; Julian Casablancas's whining voice perfectly settles on a melody that's bland just enough.

 The fourteen tracks do not seem like a faded or watered-down version but rather a natural evolution of a path characterized by strict mannerism.


By GATTINATOR

 The band’s rhythm section has improved greatly, although there are few structural innovations.

 This suggests that The Strokes have quite significant creative limitations.


By theJOKE

 The album’s production differs significantly from their truly Indie first CD, from the rawness of a low-budget production to the sparse yet effective style.

 What should have been the album of maturity still proves too immature.