Cover of Smashing Pumpkins Mellon Collie & The Infinite Sadness
blu

• Rating:

For fans of the smashing pumpkins, lovers of 90s alternative rock, listeners seeking emotionally rich and timeless albums
 Share

THE REVIEW

There are some people who have managed the rare feat of encapsulating and summarizing their entire essence within a single work, to express the infinity of their soul in all its shades and nuances through an artistic creation. I think, for example, of Roger Waters and "his" The Wall. Billy Corgan is one of these people. There are excellent artists, who have composed beautiful songs and albums, but only a few have been able to create the work of their lifetime.

This album is something beyond music, something precious that Billy wanted to gift to the world. It's not just about 28 beautiful songs, it's something more; it is the sum of everything this immense soul had inside, and he managed to miraculously bring it out in these two hours of sublime beauty. It is one of those albums, like the aforementioned The Wall, that give meaning to an entire life, after which the creator may even be an unpleasant and presumptuous guy, may even publish mediocre albums, dedicate himself to projects that are almost useless (Swan), but we will endlessly owe him gratitude, because he gave life to something sacred. How many of us feel we have something important, good, inexpressible inside? This album, which encapsulates the interiority of a man, is at the same time the voice of our most intimate feelings, our deep melancholy, and at the same time our highest and purest aspirations. Listening to this masterpiece, we are faced with everything the soul can encounter on its journey, the melancholic and dark awareness of its own limitations, the nostalgia of childhood, adolescence, of those seasons of life when our dreams seem within reach. There is Love, the awareness of its impossibility, the dull pain of overwhelming and irrational madness.

"Love is Suicide" sings good old Billy, and who doesn't feel pierced by the chilling truth that emerges from his ungraceful voice? But there is also hope, the desire to live in the fullest sense of the word, the eternal utopia, the impossible becoming possible of "Tonight tonight". And yet, the extreme sweetness, the enchantment, the need to step outside oneself, to truly communicate one's inner world. "And I'll Do Anything to Keep Her Here Tonite", and which of us hasn't felt the same? And then there is anger, the feeling of one's own impotence and the need to overcome it, to scream against a world that seems deaf and insensitive. Feeling like a "Zero", a rat in a cage, the need for escape from an oppressive reality.

And here I'll stop, but I could go on for hours, so rich is this marvelous album in ideas and emotions. I realize I haven't said much about the musical aspect of the album and I apologize, but I grew up with these songs and could only make a very personal review. I just want to say that undoubtedly the presence of the other pumpkins is not irrelevant at all, the album wouldn't have been the same without them. There is also, at the end of the first CD, a beautiful ballad written and sung by James Iha, which manages to hold its own, and that wasn't easy. In conclusion, an immense work in my opinion, superior to the rest of the group's excellent discography.

Loading comments  slowly

Summary by Bot

This review praises Mellon Collie & The Infinite Sadness as a rare artistic achievement that encapsulates Billy Corgan’s soul and emotions. The album is compared to iconic works like The Wall, expressing themes of love, melancholy, hope, and anger. The reviewer highlights the emotional impact and personal connection to the album, noting the important contributions of the other band members, especially James Iha. Overall, it is seen as a timeless masterpiece in the Smashing Pumpkins' discography.

Tracklist Lyrics Videos

01   Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness (02:52)

Read lyrics

02   Tonight, Tonight (04:14)

Read lyrics

05   Here Is No Why (03:45)

06   Bullet With Butterfly Wings (04:17)

Read lyrics

08   Fuck You (An Ode to No One) (04:50)

09   Love (04:21)

10   Cupid de Locke (02:50)

Read lyrics

13   Porcelina of the Vast Oceans (09:21)

Read lyrics

14   Take Me Down (02:52)

Read lyrics

The Smashing Pumpkins

American alternative rock band formed in Chicago and led by Billy Corgan, famed for 1990s albums such as Siamese Dream and Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness.
50 Reviews

Other reviews

By serestoppone

 Their music is like a person you know, who whispers to you, gently speaking to your heart.

 An album that if listened to, felt, and experienced helps connect ourselves with the darker sides of our ego.


By AR (Anonima Recensori)

 With this second album, there’s no need to skip for good music, because it’s very rare to find an unpleasant track.

 I don’t consider it, like many do, a masterpiece, but certainly the best in the discography of the Chicago band.


By NouQuito

 This album demonstrated that grunge had evolved into something monstrous: a gaudy AOR for the pimple-ridden MTV generation and the wanking journalists who followed the phenomenon.

 The second CD... is truly terrible, containing a series of crappy ballads with grotesque arrangements that transport us into a dimension of sterile and self-indulgent progressive.


By bramante

 An immense record (along with "Siamese Dream"), sweet and bitter at the same time, which... remains one of the most beautiful of the 'nineties'.

 Their music is a very particular fruit, difficult to replicate by other bands and... original and much less commercial than many other contemporary groups.


By Apple_of_sodomY

 The Smashing Pumpkins play 'metal', 'punk', 'alternative' and other such labels, but their music is truly poetry.

 This album remains unique and unrepeatable, for what it has given me sentimentally all this time.