A few nights ago, on a very snowy February evening, some friends and I were discussing the common concept of "pop," or at least the current (and unfortunately often derogatory) definition of the term. Perhaps it was the coziness of the beer going around, or the laid-back atmosphere while the snowstorm raged outside (alright, it's a cliché image, but absolutely true, as evidenced by various exuberant news reports on the subject); but from my "moralistic" view of music as Art, I almost reached the point of legitimizing the existence of MTV "artists" or summer hits. A concept that automatically diminished as soon as I got home and, relaxed by the quiet evening, began listening intently to an album I'd heard praised: "The Silent Corner And The Empty Stage," a work by Peter Hammill (for those who don't know, the leader of Van Der Graaf Generator) from 1974.

Without a doubt, a work that finally made me feel the same sensations as my first listen of Pawn Hearts, a few years ago. An LP to cry over, in the happiest and most radiant sense of the term. A varied yet coherent collage that pierces through the best of British music (and beyond) of the period, maintaining an exceptional and priceless personality. Technically, for the English artist we are talking about music not so far removed from the best works of the Generator (present in this LP in full): an intimate, dramatic progressive rock but never excessive, dominated by Hammill's surprising creativity. A wizard of the voice, and also a remarkable multi-instrumentalist, a great songwriter of songs and lyrics. All this creative potential channeled into works that are always interesting, often masterpieces but never less than dignified.

The opening "Modern," with its dissonances and its never cacophonous tension exemplifies the modernist side of the LP, continuing with the contrast of the calmer "Wilhelmina," exemplary in its refinement. It is an enveloping triumph of sounds that, consistent with the term progressive, starts from a "earthly" dimension of music (rock, jazz, classical, ambient) and, gathering different influences (even reaching the most acidic psychedelia with "The Red Shift"), ascends to a plane between the dreamlike and the spiritual. Grandiose words that would seem out of place for many; but not for Hammill, not for one of the greatest artists of modern English music. A secular prayer dedicated to Art, in its primary purpose: the exaltation of the interiority and the communicative urgency that only great personalities can have. All concluded with the twelve minutes of "A Louse Is Not A Home," which stands proudly alongside the historic "A Plague Of Lighthouse Keepers" from a few years earlier.

And now, writing this review and listening to this work once again, I ask myself the question again: to what extent must we legitimize the existence of yet another ephemeral pop star that daily poisons TV and radio; how can we consign to the realm of music for enthusiasts this "The Silent Corner And The Empty Stage," while the recording industry machine recycles, composes mosaics of plastic, and passes them off to you as new frontiers of sound. While albums like these remain untouchable, as if wrapped in an aura of crystal, timeless, exquisitely anchored to their era but, still in 2012, impressively relevant.

Tracklist Lyrics and Samples

01   Modern (07:28)

02   Wilhelmina (05:17)

Willie, what can I say to you
to hold true in your changing life?
You've come into a cruel world;
little girls can lose their way in the growing night...
I hope you'll be alright.

Willie, try to stay a child sometime,
for as long as you feel you can learn.
Babies all turn to people
and people can really be strange;
they change and, changing, bring pain.

Try to treat your parents well because they care,
and what more can you do?
When you find your lovers, be good to them
as you hope they'll be to you -
be honest,
be true.

Willie, you are the future;
all our lives, in the end are in your hands.
Life's hard now; you know it gets harder
and hope is but a single strand:
we pass it on and hope you'll understand....

We know that we do it wrong,
we're not so strong and not so sure at all;
groping in our blindness,
we may seem big now but, really, we're so
small and alone and searching for a home
in the night.

Meanwhile you're still a baby;
you'll be a lady soon enough
and then you will feel the burn.
So hold my words: people all turn to children,
spiteful children, and they're really so cruel,
cruel fools!

Just follow your own rules...
don't think that I'm silly, Willie,
if I say I hope that there is hope for you.

03   The Lie (Bernini's Saint Theresa) (05:41)

04   Forsaken Gardens (06:16)

05   Red Shift (08:11)

06   Rubicon (04:40)

07   A Louse Is Not a Home (12:11)

Loading comments  slowly

Other reviews

By alan clark

 "Wilhelmina, a masterpiece of voice-piano, embellished by a classic harpsichord, offers deep emotional resonance."

 "‘A Louse Is Not A Home’ is a phenomenal progressive suite ending in a powerful crescendo with exceptional saxophone and drumming."


By Rocky Marciano

 The necromancer Peter Hammill becomes here a shamanic figure, transfigured between obsessiveness and delirium.

 A work of such artistic level and monumental drama had not shone in the hands of Hammill since the days of that immortal work, 'Pawn Hearts'.