Cover of Jan Garbarek In Praise of Dreams
The Punisher

• Rating:

For fans of jan garbarek, lovers of jazz and ambient music, and listeners interested in ecm label releases.
 Share

THE REVIEW

And here we have another "sacred monster" in our hands, an untouchable now revered everywhere like the new messiah of ECM, the one who brought us "Officium" thus changing the features of that jazz-ambient of a "mystical" nature. After the half flop (intellectual, artistic, and commercial) of the follow-up "Mnemosyne" and various collaborations, our Viking saxophonist continues his verbose discographic production, giving us this time a product almost identical to that "Visible World" from almost 10 years before (it's from '95!). Similar is the structure of the tracks, the slow pace on a sly and rarefied rhythmic carpet, with the sax never exaggerated but always moderate, now a true trademark of our artist.

What did Jan want to tell us with this album? What is the artistic maturation or rather the evolution undertaken by him? Everything seems unchanged and identical as if nothing has changed, as if these 10 years have remained the same, as if the world, events, things remained outside the work of this artist who, if he produced fewer albums and thought them through better and with more attention=participation, would still have many arrows in his quiver. Instead, when the tracks are mere tedious executions (listen to the track "One Goes There Alone" rather banal if not a sterile formal exercise or little more) or "routine jobs" that add nothing to what has been done so far (listen to "Knot of Place And Time" with the sweet and almost rhetorical violin that counters the sax always the same, yet in its class and elegance), it makes you want to listen again to "Officium" or "Ragas and Sagas" or any other work from the good old days.

In confirmation of my theory of 5 max albums for each artist, after which one either retires or becomes a pianist/saxophonist in cruise ship piano bars for the wealthy. Which isn't a bad life: if things go well, you might even end up becoming the Prime Minister, just imagine...

Loading comments  slowly

Summary by Bot

The review discusses Jan Garbarek's album 'In Praise of Dreams,' pointing out its similarity to past works and a perceived lack of artistic evolution. While the saxophone playing remains elegant and moderate, some tracks feel like routine exercises. The reviewer suggests Garbarek has produced too many albums without sufficient innovation, recommending a limit for artists' output. Overall, it's a mildly critical view appreciating past works more.

Tracklist

01   As Seen From Above (04:44)

02   In Praise of Dreams (05:25)

03   One Goes There Alone (05:09)

04   Knot of Place and Time (06:27)

05   If You Go Far Enough (00:44)

06   Scene From Afar (05:19)

07   Cloud of Unknowing (05:26)

08   Without Visible Sign (05:04)

09   Iceburn (05:03)

10   Conversation With a Stone (04:25)

11   A Tale Begun (04:39)

Jan Garbarek

Jan Garbarek is a Norwegian saxophonist closely associated with ECM Records, known for a clear, spacious tone and for blending jazz with Nordic folk colors, ambient textures and sacred choral music. He has collaborated with The Hilliard Ensemble, Keith Jarrett, Charlie Haden, Bill Frisell, Kim Kashkashian, Manu Katché and others.
06 Reviews

Other reviews

By Hal

 Music in praise of dreams, to detach from the earth and remain suspended in space and time.

 Jan Garbarek's unmistakable, evocative, clear, and chilly sound of his saxophone, capable of evoking the boundless spaces of his homeland.